New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: Kalyani
in reply to a message by tara
No, no--the last thing I want to imply is that you're some kind of ignorant, racist jerk. :( I'm sure you're a very nice person.
It's a complicated issue, because of the possibility of being condescending and inadvertantly dumb about this kind of thing. You know the type--the ladies who go, "Oh, I named my daughter Jaci, which, in the Native American culture, represents the moon." And what they've really done is changed the spelling of a trendy name so that it's vaguely legitimate, made no effort to show any respect for the culture that it comes from (gee, the "Native American" culture? They're all homogenous, feathers-and-rain-dances in your mind, aren't they?), and they look at that culture with a weird, romanticized condescension. (I was just sitting in class with a girl like this, actually--she talked about how people from non-Western countries have it so much harder than we do (the implication being that without all the luxuries of white America, their lives are pointless), and she thinks that you can tell as much in their music, which just sounds so sorrowful and sad. And then the professor pointed out that what we were listening to was actually from a wedding ceremony. I just wanted to smack that girl, ferreals.)
But if you (you general) happen to love, say Suzume, you pronounce it as accurately as is possible in your accent, and you don't act like you're some kind of amazingly open-minded and special person for using this or that name? I really think it should be okay. Non-French people use Simone, non-Norwegians use Ingrid, non-Italians use Bianca. And if non-Arabs love Noor or non-Yorubans think Dayo is lovely, I see no reason why they should be told, "No, you don't look right."
This is a multi-cultural world. Trying to keep everyone in the "right" pigeonholes is unnecessary and small-minded (again, not trying to say that you are, since the question of "what would a Mexican think of Norwegian Juan?" is a fair question--I just don't think there should be a problem).
Does that make sense? It's an issue that's hard for me to keep my focus on, because there are so many related things I want to drag in with it.
Array
It's a complicated issue, because of the possibility of being condescending and inadvertantly dumb about this kind of thing. You know the type--the ladies who go, "Oh, I named my daughter Jaci, which, in the Native American culture, represents the moon." And what they've really done is changed the spelling of a trendy name so that it's vaguely legitimate, made no effort to show any respect for the culture that it comes from (gee, the "Native American" culture? They're all homogenous, feathers-and-rain-dances in your mind, aren't they?), and they look at that culture with a weird, romanticized condescension. (I was just sitting in class with a girl like this, actually--she talked about how people from non-Western countries have it so much harder than we do (the implication being that without all the luxuries of white America, their lives are pointless), and she thinks that you can tell as much in their music, which just sounds so sorrowful and sad. And then the professor pointed out that what we were listening to was actually from a wedding ceremony. I just wanted to smack that girl, ferreals.)
But if you (you general) happen to love, say Suzume, you pronounce it as accurately as is possible in your accent, and you don't act like you're some kind of amazingly open-minded and special person for using this or that name? I really think it should be okay. Non-French people use Simone, non-Norwegians use Ingrid, non-Italians use Bianca. And if non-Arabs love Noor or non-Yorubans think Dayo is lovely, I see no reason why they should be told, "No, you don't look right."
This is a multi-cultural world. Trying to keep everyone in the "right" pigeonholes is unnecessary and small-minded (again, not trying to say that you are, since the question of "what would a Mexican think of Norwegian Juan?" is a fair question--I just don't think there should be a problem).
Does that make sense? It's an issue that's hard for me to keep my focus on, because there are so many related things I want to drag in with it.
Array
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
i see your point. i live in a very secluded bubble of the world and i don't see much racism at all, thankfully. i see that in mainstream America someone might think how hip it is to name their child some ethnic name without respect or knowledge about the culture, etc. i haven't encountered this in my time, but it sounds legitimate for sure.
So, thanks!
tara
So, thanks!
tara
1
Very well thought out and expressed, Array!
n/t
n/t
1