View Message

[Opinions] Hester
I'm currently wrapping up The Scarlet Letter, and I'm totally loving it. Of course, reading the book has put the name Hester into my mind. I love Esther (and yet never really considered using it as a FN), but there's something about Hester that really attracts me. It might be that I just like the character Hester Prynne. So, I'd like your opinions on the name-- is it too harsh or "old" feeling, etc. WDYT?Also, a related question: based on The Scarlet Letter, do you think it would be weird to have a hypothetical son and daughter named Hester and Arthur? Does that fall into Romeo and Juliet territory? I kind of feel like it should, but then again, the minister is Dimmesdale to me, not Arthur. Do you think it's too much?Thanks in advance, guys. :)
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Well, I'm not really a fan of Arthur but Hester is nice. I don't think Hester sounds too old until you put it with Arthur, plus I would definitely think of The Scarlet Letter with those two names together, but not separate. Go with Hester, not Arthur. :-)
vote up1
Hester is all right, imo, but I especially like Esther. BTW, The Scarlet Letter is what makes me love the name Pearl so much, I think. As for Hester & Arthur...eh, that really doesn't sit right w/me. Yes, the minister is referred to Dimmesdale most of the time, but he's so *evil*! Arthur by itself connotes King Arthur, but Arthur & Hester give me a baaad vibe. :o/ On the other hand, Arthur & Esther / Ester don't bother me. Edited b/c I used "really" about 4 times.

This message was edited 8/10/2007, 9:50 AM

vote up1
Hester reminds me of jester and I have never liked the name for that reason. I also don't particularly like the namesake from the book. I would much rather use the name Pearl.
vote up1
Hester is gorgeous!!!!
Arthur is gorgeous!!!!!!
.......but.....not together! Yes I just think its too Romeo and Juliet. Individually lovely names but together you just couldn't do that to your children. It would be unfair. :(
vote up1