View Message

New Post
Search
Help
[Opinions] Nathan vs. Nathaniel
by Eliora (guest)
8/28/2007, 1:51 PM
Nathaniel is the one name I've been able to agree on with my boyfriend. However, I've begun to like Nathan just a bit more. I'm curious as to people's opinions. Nathaniel has better namesakes to me, but Nathan is just easier. TIA
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

- Brianna (Brianna Angela)
8/30/2007, 12:52 PM
I like Nathaniel nn Nathan
vote up1
- Array (WeloveyouJesseLacey)
8/28/2007, 8:12 PM
I prefer Nathaniel, personally--first there's Nat from Little Men and Jo's Boys, who turned me onto the name in the first place, then dear Natty-boy of Bartimaeus, and then the eternally-sexy Nathaniel Hawthorne. Nathan, on the other hand, has Nathan Fillion of Firefly and not much else. Plus, every Nathan I've known has been a total jerk. So I definitely like Nathaniel better.Array
vote up1
- Pink Princess
8/28/2007, 7:26 PM
Well I think Nathaniel is nice, but I can't stand Nathan! Weird huh? Nathaniel just sounds more masculine and interesting to me.
vote up1
- mum2bubba
8/28/2007, 5:16 PM
I prefer just Nathan by itself. Skye's name was going to be Nathan if she was a boy.
vote up1
- Elaine (Elaina Brigitta)   +5
8/28/2007, 4:22 PM
I can't stand Nathan. It's so harsh. Nathaniel however is only of my favorite names. It's more elegant, mature, and less trendy. Plus, you could always shorten Nathaniel to Nathan (or Nate or Nat) if you wanted.
vote up1
- Eliora (eliorafalk)   +4
8/28/2007, 4:27 PM
Nathan and Nathaniel are pretty close in popularity stats.Doesn't make much of a difference.
vote up1
- blaaarg
8/28/2007, 4:32 PM
I disagreeIf you look closer, at least for 2006, you'll see that
nathan:0.651%
nathaniel:0.302%which means you're twice as likely to meet a Nathan as a Nathaniel.
vote up1
- Elaine (Elaina Brigitta)   +2
8/28/2007, 4:31 PM
23 to 69 is bit of a difference, at least for me. I suppose I just get more of a trendy feel from Nathan.

This message was edited 8/28/2007, 4:32 PM

vote up1
- Eilis (Suibhne)   +1
8/28/2007, 6:05 PM
TrendyTrendy isn't exactly the word I'd use for Nathan, but I do feel that there's something slightly dated about it. Just a hinted of dated-ness, you know?
vote up1
- Array (WeloveyouJesseLacey)
8/28/2007, 8:13 PM
Agreed.Nathan sounds like he'd be Ashley and Kaitlyn's classmate, along with his brother, Zachary. Much too 80s/90s for my tastes.Array
vote up1
- Mommy2B
8/28/2007, 2:54 PM
I prefer Nathanv
vote up1
- Eilis (Suibhne)
8/28/2007, 2:05 PM
I know easily twice as many Nathaniels as I do Nathans, so if the ease that you're considering comes from it being a shorter name, I wouldn't worry about it. Nathaniel's a pretty easy one for people to grasp. If your preference for Nathan isn't that strong, and you both agree on Nathaniel, I recommend going with Nathan as a nickname. As a matter of interest, without exception every Nathaniel or Nathan I know goes by Nate. And after Christopher and variants of Eric, it easily competes to be one of the top most popular names of my personal acquaintances.
vote up1
- LadyBug (LadyBug18)
8/28/2007, 2:02 PM
I love both names but tend toward Nathaniel as being more handsome, less trendy in sound, more possible nicknames (not just Nate, Nathan, Nat but also Niel / Neil or even Eli from the ending letters). I also love it's connection on my family tree (Nathan can also be found there but not as direct an ancestor). So anyway, Nathaniel is my suggestion.
vote up1
- Amanda (Manda_Bear)
8/28/2007, 1:54 PM
I know a Nathan who goes by Nathan, a Nathan who goes by Nate, a Nathaniel who goes by Nate, and a Nathaniel who goes by Nathan. Personally, I think Nathan is more handsome and, as you said, easier. Especially if you're going to call him Nate or Nathan anyway, just leave the '-iel' off, unless you're honoring or something...
vote up1