New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Twin combos
We watched a movie in my gender class yesterday, and I was wondering what you thought about the Twins combos. The movie was about a set of twins where one penis was burnt off from circumcision in the 50 or 60s. The parents had him undergo surgery to become a female, however, later in life he underwent surgery again to change back into a female.
At birth:
Bruce and Brian
As toddlers through early teens:
Brenda and Brian
As adults:
David and Brian
It was an interesting movie to say the least, really hit people with evidence that nuture may not have much of a cause as some like to think.
At birth:
Bruce and Brian
As toddlers through early teens:
Brenda and Brian
As adults:
David and Brian
It was an interesting movie to say the least, really hit people with evidence that nuture may not have much of a cause as some like to think.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
1
typo
the last word of your first paragraph should be 'male' instead of 'female'..:)
I saw the documentary too, i like the names, they're not too twinsy..:)
!!!!!!!, ??? and ~~~~~, see my profile for their names!
the last word of your first paragraph should be 'male' instead of 'female'..:)
I saw the documentary too, i like the names, they're not too twinsy..:)
!!!!!!!, ??? and ~~~~~, see my profile for their names!
1
A very tragic story
I think Bruce and Brian, as well as Brenda and Brian sound nice. Not too similar. Though I think many dislike "twinsy" names, so David and Brian seems more modern thinking.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
I think Bruce and Brian, as well as Brenda and Brian sound nice. Not too similar. Though I think many dislike "twinsy" names, so David and Brian seems more modern thinking.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
1
That is soooo horrible. I can't believe someone would do that to their son. Poor guy. I wonder if he has an identity crisis.
Aria
Aria
1
The parents followed their doctor's advice
They though if Bruce was brought up as a girl (and later got female hormones), then this was the best solution.
When Bruce found out the truth, he underwent surgery to look like a man. He said he never felt comfortable as a girl. He married and got step-children.
But his brother Brian committed suicide. Later, after loosing a lot of money, Bruce/David also comitted suicide.
I think the whole thing was such a trauma that the sons were affected for life.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
They though if Bruce was brought up as a girl (and later got female hormones), then this was the best solution.
When Bruce found out the truth, he underwent surgery to look like a man. He said he never felt comfortable as a girl. He married and got step-children.
But his brother Brian committed suicide. Later, after loosing a lot of money, Bruce/David also comitted suicide.
I think the whole thing was such a trauma that the sons were affected for life.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
This message was edited 9/20/2005, 8:21 AM
1
Geez! You think!? I would be affected for life too if I found out that I was really a man. That would be just a 'little' scary.
Aria
Aria
1
Everything seemed to be ok for a while
David got a a big sum in damages, he had a family and a job. But then he lost his job, he invested his money unwisely and left his family.
But the fact that his twin brother also committed suicide shows that the family just could not cope. The brothers were not even close.
But plastic surgery was not as advanced in those times, so I can see why they though "changing him into a girl" was the best thing to do.
Personally I can't see why parents cicumcise their sons (unless they have strong religious reasons as Jews or Muslims). Why take the risk? Why fix something that isn't broken?
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
David got a a big sum in damages, he had a family and a job. But then he lost his job, he invested his money unwisely and left his family.
But the fact that his twin brother also committed suicide shows that the family just could not cope. The brothers were not even close.
But plastic surgery was not as advanced in those times, so I can see why they though "changing him into a girl" was the best thing to do.
Personally I can't see why parents cicumcise their sons (unless they have strong religious reasons as Jews or Muslims). Why take the risk? Why fix something that isn't broken?
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
1
""Personally I can't see why parents cicumcise their sons (unless they have strong religious reasons as Jews or Muslims). Why take the risk? Why fix something that isn't broken?""
American Academy of Pediatrics has only within the past maybe 5 yrs or so NOT recommended circumcision. Previously, it had been pretty much routinely done in the US.
American Academy of Pediatrics has only within the past maybe 5 yrs or so NOT recommended circumcision. Previously, it had been pretty much routinely done in the US.
1
Extra incomes for the doctors
I suspect this is the reason the doctors did not speak out before.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
I suspect this is the reason the doctors did not speak out before.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
1
Circumcising is supposed to prevent males from getting certian deseases. I'm not sure which ones, but everyone I know has gotten their baby boys circumcized. It's not a religious thing at all as far as I know, just safety.
1
Actually I did read an article saying that the rates of transmission of the AIDS virus were less in circumcized men then in uncircumcized men. If I can find the link I'll post it.
1
I actually went through this argument with my mom
When she found out my ex was uncut. She went ahead and went through the research (she's a nurse at a pretty well-known and respected hospital) and discovered that was incorrect.
I also went ahead and did research, checking and rechecking. I spoke to several people. All of it proved that it was incorrect
When she found out my ex was uncut. She went ahead and went through the research (she's a nurse at a pretty well-known and respected hospital) and discovered that was incorrect.
I also went ahead and did research, checking and rechecking. I spoke to several people. All of it proved that it was incorrect
1
In Europe men have managed quite well without circumcision
And the same goes for Asia (apart from Muslim areas). So I really think this is incorrect and more old (bad imo) tradition.
After all, female circumcisions is also a bad tradition. We condemn this but without condemning male circumcision, it is a bit hypocritical. Surgery without medical reasons in both cases.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
And the same goes for Asia (apart from Muslim areas). So I really think this is incorrect and more old (bad imo) tradition.
After all, female circumcisions is also a bad tradition. We condemn this but without condemning male circumcision, it is a bit hypocritical. Surgery without medical reasons in both cases.
"You sought a flower and found a fruit. You sought a spring and found a sea. You sought a woman and found a soul. You are disappointed."
"It does not become me to make myself smaller than I am." (Edith Södergran 1891-1923)
1
1