New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] I dislike both (m)
in reply to a message by The Little Hyphen
Everyone here seems to love them, and I really dislike them. They both come across as names a whiny child would have. On top of that, I'm starting to get sick of boys names that start with Jo-, which doesn't help. As far as your sibset goes, it goes well and I don't think they're too similar to the other names. I just don't like either of them.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Thats fair enough. I don't like the nn Joe and I would actively discourage it on a child called Jonah or Jonas. I feel like it isn't quite such an inevitable nn as it would be on a child called Joseph, or is that really naive, lol? Any reasons as to why it seems 'whiny' or just a feeling? Thanks for your input.
1
No, it's not inevitable. None of the Jonahs I've known have ever been Joe, and all the Josephs have.
1
That makes me feel a bit better! Did they go by any other nicknames?
1
A little history
Jonas is the Greek form of Jonah used in the New Testament, so both names have the same history/meaning. Biblically, Jonah was a Jewish prophet who God sent to evangelize the people of Ninevah. The people of Ninevah were despised, and Jonah refused to minister to them, and took a ship headed to another city. There was a storm and Jonah told the crew to throw him into the sea to save themselves. After Jonah is thrown into the sea, the storm subsides and a fish swallows Jonah. Jonah stays in the belly of the fish for three days until the fish vomits him up on the land. Jonah then (still unwillingly) goes to the people of Ninevah and many repent. It is also mentioned that Jonah would rest under a fig tree for the shade, and God sent a worm to kill the fig tree. The fig tree died and Jonah mourned the loss of the tree. God then asks Jonah why he mourned for the loss of a tree but did not care for the loss of people (those in Ninevah).
So, Jonah was a prophet, but he is remembered for rebelling against God, reluctance to obey, and being callously self-centered. So this may be where the "whiny" comes from.
Jonas is the Greek form of Jonah used in the New Testament, so both names have the same history/meaning. Biblically, Jonah was a Jewish prophet who God sent to evangelize the people of Ninevah. The people of Ninevah were despised, and Jonah refused to minister to them, and took a ship headed to another city. There was a storm and Jonah told the crew to throw him into the sea to save themselves. After Jonah is thrown into the sea, the storm subsides and a fish swallows Jonah. Jonah stays in the belly of the fish for three days until the fish vomits him up on the land. Jonah then (still unwillingly) goes to the people of Ninevah and many repent. It is also mentioned that Jonah would rest under a fig tree for the shade, and God sent a worm to kill the fig tree. The fig tree died and Jonah mourned the loss of the tree. God then asks Jonah why he mourned for the loss of a tree but did not care for the loss of people (those in Ninevah).
So, Jonah was a prophet, but he is remembered for rebelling against God, reluctance to obey, and being callously self-centered. So this may be where the "whiny" comes from.
1
Nope, just from people I know. I'm not a fan of Biblical names either, though. They're not really my thing.
1