View Message

[Opinions] Elsa or Cheyenne?
Most of you know that my favorite combo is Elsa Cheyenne. Both names are honoring (but they don't honor the same person). At the moment I'd like to call her Cheyenne nn Chey (pronounced like Shy) but Elsa is growing on me. I always liked it but in the last few days I really began to love it.Elsa or Cheyenne? and WHY?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Elsa
vote up1
Elsa
vote up1
CheyenneMaybe on principle I'd prefer Elsa, but in practical application I can't stand it. I think it's just dumpy and homely. It has what a friend of mine calls "thrift store mafia" essence all over it; it seems like it'd be a sort of smug, quasi-alternative option that would have been someone's alleged darling "before it was popular."

This message was edited 3/12/2009, 3:43 AM

vote up1
That's quite an analysis! I love the term "thrift store mafia"!!
However, since the poster says the name is meant to honor a friend, if I were the her I wouldn't worry about such judgments.

I had a friend named Elsa whose parents were (Christian) immigrants from India. It did seem a little bit quaint, but definitely cool. I guess the personality of the bearer makes the biggest impression.
vote up1
For the love of all that's holy -- Elsa!Elsa is one of my favorite names. Beautiful, feminine, underused, classy. Cheyenne is tacky and unattractive, imo, probably one of my least favorite names ever, if not THE least favorite.
vote up1
This
vote up1
ElsaI like Elsa; it is cute and classy. I think I'd like Elisa a little more, though.
But I vastly prefer Elsa over Cheyenne.
(vote on my names? http://www.babynames.com/namelist/9516801)
vote up1
Cheyenne. I hate Elsa although Im not too keen on Cheyenne either
vote up1
vote up1
Elsa, easilySorry, but Cheyenne sounds kind of trashy to me. Elsa is cute.
vote up1
I don't particularity like either, but between the two......I'd go with Elsa. It will age better and who knows, maybe it will be one of the next names to be revived. It's got that old-lady spark to it! :)
vote up1
Ditto.Elsa is simpering to me, but myriad times better than Cheyenne.
vote up1
I love Cheyenne.
vote up1
I like it all together, and that's it. It flows nicely, and the contrast is great. I don't like either name individually. For Cheyenne, you can just look to others' comments. As for Elsa, I disagree with some there, especially about it being uncommon or refreshing. Sometimes "simple" is just simple. I wouldn't take my opinion, though, as there are very few short names I like. Elsa stood no chance with me. It sounds nice, yeah, but it's a few letters too short. ;)

This message was edited 3/11/2009, 2:52 PM

vote up1
ElsaElsa will age better and it isn't trendy like Cheyenne. Cheyenne is just tacky to me. Elsa is just simple and pretty to me where Cheyenne doesn't sound nice to my ears.
vote up1
Definitely Elsa!It's soo amazing, and everytime I see your Elsa Cheyenne combo (which is like every other post!), I get so sad when you say "Elsa Cheyenne, called Cheyenne", because it's such a waste of the prettier name in the combo. It actually has made me start to hate Cheyenne, I get so mad at it for taking over Elsa's more deserved spot!
vote up1
CheyenneBecause I think it's a very pretty name (in both pronunciation and spelling) although it may not have such a nice meaning. Although Elsa has a better meaning, I do not like it because it seems too old-fashioned and sounds like an old lady name. My cousin's cat was also named Elsa.
vote up1
From the sounds alone, Cheyenne. From the connotations, definitely Elsa. I dislike both names, though. Elsa seems dated and dowdy and Cheyenne, well, not so classy. I'd choose Elsa if I had to name my daughter either one of those.
vote up1
Elsa hands down
vote up1
ElsaCheyenne is tacky and cheap sounding. It is super trendy and will not age well IMO. Now, if it does honour then use it in the mn position, and keep it in the mn position (i.e. don't refer to her as Cheyenne nn Chey). Elsa, on the other hand, is strong, refreshing and has an amazing history and is not trendy or common but is easily recognisable and easy to pronounce. All the things to look for in a great name IMO.
vote up1
well put
vote up1
Yep, thisBesides, Elsa just sounds a million times better with Kaia and Noelle. Plus, I adore the nn Elsie.

This message was edited 3/12/2009, 1:12 AM

vote up1
Ditto
vote up1
Ditto, butI would much rather see Elsa as a nickname. It's a little cutesy alone.
vote up1
Complete ditto.
vote up1
Agree.
vote up1
Agreed.
vote up1
Tritto.,€
vote up1
Ditto, exactly.
vote up1
Elsa all the way
vote up1