View Message

[Opinions] Alix & Tristan
I am thinking about these two names today. Would you agree that, while of a classic historical origin, they sound too trendy, and create apprehension to use them?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I like them, but they both have a threat of trendiness looming over them that would make me avoid them if I was naming a child. Tristan used to be higher up than Tristram on my list, but now it's the opposite way around. I've used Alix on a character, but I'd sooner use Alice IRL.
vote up1
I don't think either sound trendy. If anything, Tristan seems slightly dated to the late 90s to me (whether its popularity actually reflects that, I don't know!). But I think Tristan is quite knightly. And Alix is very elegant and beautiful. I think it could possibly lean towards hipster, but I've never heard of it being used in real life.
vote up1
No. Tristan to me is ageless. I don't care how popular it gets, It will forever retain it's beauty. It's a classic, just like Christian, handsome no matter what. Alix on the other hand - I really dislike this spelling, it 'is' trendy, and I really don't like trendy names. They try too hard to be different, yet end up looking silly. This is a great case point. Alex is ok as nn for Alexander, which is very handsome. But I get the feeling the spelling of Alix would appeal to parents seeking out boys names to use on a girl. I don't know why, that's the feeling I get from it. Strangely, I dislike Alexandra, but it's better than Alix.
vote up1
The only reason Tristan "creates apprehension" for me is because I was bullied by a girl in middle school named Tristan. So I can't like it. I like Alix though. I like the look of it. Much better than Alex.
vote up1
Create apprehension?http://www.dailywritingtips.com/big-words-make-you-sound-smart-dont-they/ - I think you might find that interesting.Anyway: Neither are my style. I far prefer Alys to Alix, not sure why. I think I like the look of it better. Tristan has always been too romantic for my style. Alix, though, is totally usable, as is Tristan. :-D
vote up1
why
vote up1
Perhaps you should read more. Apprehension is not an especially difficult word.
vote up1
I thought "create apprehension" was completely appropriate. Just sayin'
vote up1
Maybe. I just thought it was an odd way to say it - plus the article is interesting.I apologize if I offended.
vote up1
I really liked the article, and I sure didn't want to offend you either! Sometimes I forget that posting disagreement online doesn't come out as non-serious as I mean it :)
vote up1
I like Tristan I do agree its trendy but I really think its a great boys name.Alixandre is my preference with Alix has a nn. A little trendy/creative in todays society but there was a Princess Alix which makes me like it more.
Princess Alix Marie Anna Antoinette Charlotte Gabriell of Ligne
and the close
Princess Maria Alix Luitpolda Anna Henriette Germana Agnes Damiana Michaela of Saxony

This message was edited 7/15/2010, 3:01 PM

vote up1
Queen Victoria's dd Alice changed her name to Alix (form of Alice) when she married a German aristocrat (from Hesse, I think). Her dd Alix married Tsar Nicholas II and changed her name to Alexandra when she became Empress of Russia. Also, I believe Eleanor of Acquitaine had a dd Alix, daughter of Louis of France. However, spellings were so random back then it's hard to really use this one as a firm "Alix." Did you mean any other Alix? I love the name and would appreciate any other historic references that you or anyone else can provide. Thanks.

This message was edited 7/15/2010, 3:04 PM

vote up1
Other historical references:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alix,_Duchess_of_Brittanyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alix_de_MontmorencyMore modern, this link is about a niece of Prince Rainier of Monaco:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christine_Alix_de_MassyThis is kind of interesting. This comic book has a male character called Alix.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alix
vote up1
Wow. I had no idea there were others, especially current ones. Yippee! Thanks for the links.
vote up1
I edited my message to include Alix of Ligne and Maria Alix of Saxony but yes I was in my head thinking of Queen Victorias daughter Alice who changed to Alix. I too love historical references! Especially princess (I am so girly its not funny)
vote up1
Yes. I had a brainwave the other day that Prince William and Catherine (forgot her surname) marry. Their first child would be named Victoria Alice Helen Louise after Queen Victoria's first four dds. Wills and Catherine would call her Alix. So: Victoria Alice Helen Louise, nn Alix?
vote up1
I reserve the term "trendy" for names without history / meaning; they pop up out of nowhwere and are therefore likely to leave quickly.Traditional names that are popular are not "trendy" for me. So Alix and Tristan sound perfectly lovely to me. They really do well together, as a sibling set. Tristan brings out an almost chivalric quality in Alix. I keep thinking of lances with sharp tips when I see Alix next to Tristan. Fun.
vote up1
nail on the headThat is my exact interpretation of Tristan, Chivalric! I couldnt put words on but you did! Thank you
vote up1