Message: "Re: Katrelle... Katriel... Katniss..."

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] Re: Katrelle... Katriel... Katniss...

by glaucous

4/25/2012, 6:39 PM

I don't know about The Hunger Games reference, but I hate Katniss. I don't think they're that similar...it seems sort of like equating Albert with Alvin, or Willard with William.

I see what you mean about the made-up aspect, which is my main reservation: it strikes me as possibly ditzy-sounding (which is a characteristic I ascribe to made-up names). But on the other hand, all variations of classic names were at some point made up...which I guess is why I was asking the question.

Actually, objectively, if I hadn't heard this name in real life, I doubt I would like it (for the reasons you stated), but since I have and I recall it positively, I don't think I can view it as 'juvenile' or tacky...

This message was edited 4/25/2012, 6:45 PM

Replies

- Francesca

4/27/2012, 7:50 AM

Albert and Alvin, Willard and William-- both groupings are vey established names, and would never be as closely paralleled with eachother (though if there was a family of men bearing Willard, who named their son William (or a variant), it is logical to assume that there is an honoring factor.)

If someone approached me in the real world with their consideration of Katrelle / Katriel, I would be lying if I did not say that I thought of The Hunger Game (which is such a mammoth focus within our culture, currently; it is believable.) Unless it is already traditional and rooted in society, I am drawn to think that many Kat- names will eventually have someones' mind (especially a hopeful fan) flicker.

I understand. If it is a name that you are strongly bonded to, Katriel definitely looks more professional and complete.

- Francesca

View Message

Replies