New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: Elliott for a girl +Question
in reply to a message by Entity
I am not a huge fan, but have heard it before. I guess it's just as usable as Brett or Hunter for a girl.
QUESTION:
Why do people pick these unexpected names (like Elliott for a girl) and then revert to a totally acceptable and common nickname such as Ell?
Defeats the point amiright?
______________________________________________
Mama to Clarisse and Nadine.
Mahal na mahal from our little family to yours!
QUESTION:
Why do people pick these unexpected names (like Elliott for a girl) and then revert to a totally acceptable and common nickname such as Ell?
Defeats the point amiright?
______________________________________________
Mama to Clarisse and Nadine.
Mahal na mahal from our little family to yours!
This message was edited 8/12/2016, 7:28 AM
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1
Replies
Personally I prefer more feminine names for girls with masculine or unisex nn's and more masculine names for boys with feminine or unisex nn's. Though I also like the opposite and I also like masculine nn's for boys and feminine nn's for girls.
Some people like more masculine names for girls or feminine names for boys. A lot of those people like the nn's to match the child's gender possibly so the child has something to fall back on if they dislike their name. Most of the time unfortunately people like masculine names for girls and masculine names for boys. Not many people are comfortable with more feminine names for boys.
-----------------
Some people like more masculine names for girls or feminine names for boys. A lot of those people like the nn's to match the child's gender possibly so the child has something to fall back on if they dislike their name. Most of the time unfortunately people like masculine names for girls and masculine names for boys. Not many people are comfortable with more feminine names for boys.
-----------------
1
I agree with your response - exponentially. While some nick-names may just be short forms of the formal, Nick-names also offer a choice against the formal for the name bearer, so if a girl or guy feels estranged by this quality, s/he may obscure the distinction. Also if parents or guardians realize that the child responds better or prefers the shorter nick-name, the shorter name would more naturally become the moniker. Another possibility, and this one hits close to home, is that the unexpected quality of the name (gender) is not the reason that the person bears this name, as I myself was named after a recently departed aunt, so the idea "let's give him a girl's name" sustained less merit in the wake of recent tragedy, which, through periods of grief, would impose conflict on one already in mourning, and even if considered, might not be suggested at all by the less affected parent. Yet in any situation, a parent or name giver may simply like a name--and the partner might have already agreed to it, assuming that it would be for a girl. When asked about my own unique name assignment last year, I did not easily offer the explanation, as natural conditions of loss, consolation, and remembrance--and the continuity of it all surround my name; yet while of course there is more to it, this is another reason that I cherish it--yet also guard it from degradation, and endeavor such for other names, as I do.
While writing this, I tried to remove myself from the situation and involve anyone with a unique name, but I found myself reverting back to my own name & my understanding of the circumstance which involved its assignment; so I found this response to be cathartic. As unique as my name might be, there is natural empathy Behind the Name--but also regular, daily, normal human interaction, which during periods of loss, which later perpetuates, bears more upon the heart than the black and white characters which dispel it.
When young, I always thought Brett to be a name for girls / females, due to the "ett" sound--i.e. the noun "barrette", Paulette, Collette...; as any guy named Brett would have 'girl's name' as I do. I still have this perception, though I fully understand now that it is more frequently used as a name for males.
While writing this, I tried to remove myself from the situation and involve anyone with a unique name, but I found myself reverting back to my own name & my understanding of the circumstance which involved its assignment; so I found this response to be cathartic. As unique as my name might be, there is natural empathy Behind the Name--but also regular, daily, normal human interaction, which during periods of loss, which later perpetuates, bears more upon the heart than the black and white characters which dispel it.
When young, I always thought Brett to be a name for girls / females, due to the "ett" sound--i.e. the noun "barrette", Paulette, Collette...; as any guy named Brett would have 'girl's name' as I do. I still have this perception, though I fully understand now that it is more frequently used as a name for males.
1