View Message

[Opinions] Archer or Archie?
Which do you prefer?I live is Australia where both names are in use. I've always preferred Archer as a full name with Archie as a nn (I really do have a thing for surnames as FNs) but I always enjoy hearing the softer Archie as a full name. So, thoughts?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I prefer Archer, but I'm not a fan of either.
vote up1
ArcherArcher is an interesting combination of modern tastes with an ancient occupation. It isn't a name I would use, but I definitely prefer it to Archie. Archie is dated, incomplete, and juvenile sounding. I think it has been in decline with the rise of the Archie comic strip. It sounds very British to me and kind of wet.

This message was edited 3/4/2019, 8:22 PM

vote up1
ArchieI like both, but I love the energy and fun of Archie.
vote up1
Archie.(:
vote up1
I don't like Archer abstractly as a word/occupational name, but I think I'd prefer it to having Archie on official documents, even though I like Archie as a NN.
vote up1
Archer or Archie is a gp.
vote up1
I prefer Archie. It's cute and sweet. Archer sounds like an occupation.
vote up1
Far and away Archer!Archer is more of a GP for me than something I'd actually use, but I've always loved it. I don't like nickname first names, and even without that I just don't love Archie. Despite the similar sounds, the feel of the two names couldn't be more different to me.
vote up1
Archie is too nicknamey on its own, Archibald has an unpleasant sound with that “bald” right in there. Archer is too trendy and surnamey. Honestly, I’m not big on the whole lot.Asher and Arthur are both similar and very nice.
vote up1
This
vote up1
*Edith Bunker voice* AAAHHHHHHH-CHIEEEEEEEE???!!!lol sorry, but All in the Family is my first association, and if I'm honest, all they ever did on that show was yell and it hurt my ears. Sorry to any fans out there.Anyway, I actually prefer Asher over both of them. Archer isn't my style, and I already expressed my opinion on Archie.
vote up1
HAHAHAHA LOL!(:
vote up1
Archer is both a lnfn and somewhat - medievally - militaristic, so I'd avoid it without a backward glance.I would expect anyone called Archie to have Archibald as his full name. Not a name I enjoy; the bald bit puts me right off. But Archie is pleasant.
vote up1
"Archer is both a lnfn and somewhat - medievally - militaristic, so I'd avoid it without a backward glance."You must not have enjoyed Robin Hood, Lord of the Rings (Legolas), Narnia, or Hunger Games if you have something against archers. I agree that occupation names and last names are overdone, but as occupations names go, archers at least have lots of positive representation. *I'm kind of joking here, so don't be offended.*

This message was edited 3/4/2019, 8:32 PM

vote up1
In works of fiction, I've got nothing against invasions of alien spacecraft ... in real life, however ..;)
vote up1
Hi !!!Archie is too nicknamey and Archer is an old-fave of mine but now has becoming boring.Archibald has my vote! Great meaning, nice sound, dignified and underused.

This message was edited 3/2/2019, 1:31 AM

vote up1