New Post
Search
Help[Opinions] Re: Emilia and Amelia
in reply to a message by Fiammetta
They sound same enough that I can't usually tell them apart when spoken. When I'm speaking quickly and not paying attention, they're both umMEELya.
Like Anneza says, the initial unstressed vowel goes all soft. A reason why I don't prefer names that have it. They sound too much like "uh, Melia" or *uh, Lizabeth."
But they should be slightly different, and I *feel* like I"m saying them differently when I think about it. I do try to distinguish them, when I'm mentioning the Emilia I have met, and don't want people to mishear her name as Amelia.
Emilia starts like "embargo" and has a shorter I - em-MILL-ya, and Amelia is am-MEAL-ya, starts like "ambivalent" and has an EEL sound. So they *could* sound different in English, if you wanted to distinguish them, and it wouldn't be weird.
To me Amelia seems sort of aging and prim, but more librarian than matron, and pretty. At best it's like Olivia and Camilla - names I don't see as youthful or energetic, but they seem to have become perceived that way recently.
Emilia seems European, less 'traditional English,' and more youthful and sophisticated. It's a little less "foreign"/Euro than Gianna, a little more so than Isabella.
- mirfak
Like Anneza says, the initial unstressed vowel goes all soft. A reason why I don't prefer names that have it. They sound too much like "uh, Melia" or *uh, Lizabeth."
But they should be slightly different, and I *feel* like I"m saying them differently when I think about it. I do try to distinguish them, when I'm mentioning the Emilia I have met, and don't want people to mishear her name as Amelia.
Emilia starts like "embargo" and has a shorter I - em-MILL-ya, and Amelia is am-MEAL-ya, starts like "ambivalent" and has an EEL sound. So they *could* sound different in English, if you wanted to distinguish them, and it wouldn't be weird.
To me Amelia seems sort of aging and prim, but more librarian than matron, and pretty. At best it's like Olivia and Camilla - names I don't see as youthful or energetic, but they seem to have become perceived that way recently.
Emilia seems European, less 'traditional English,' and more youthful and sophisticated. It's a little less "foreign"/Euro than Gianna, a little more so than Isabella.
- mirfak
This message was edited 6/10/2019, 9:48 AM
Archived Thread - replies disabled
1