View Message

[Opinions] Jacob & Alida
I have a book about my family tree going as far back as 1618. From the third generation (1670s) two names are repeated throughout the rest of the generations.Jacob & Alida- What do you think of these names?
- How do you pronounce the name Alida? a-LIE-da, a-LEE-da?
ED9-E39-BE-B758-4-AC6-85-E7-7054-F657-D762
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Jacob isn’t really appealing to me. I prefer Judoc.
Alida is nice, but kinda just looks like another Alina or Eliza. I pronounce it “a-LEE-da”.
vote up1
I love the way they sound together, Jacob is a cute, simple and timeless name and Alida sounds lovely and elegant and I'm surprised I don't see or hear of more people named Alida. I'd probably pronounce it a-LEE-da, I also like Aleida pronounced a-LAY-da, it's a name I'd consider for a literary character.
vote up1
Jacob is outdated/boring compared to Alida/
Alida = a-LIE-daSuggestions:
Alida Rose
Alida Faith
Alida Kennedy
Alida May
Alida Lynn
Alida Wren
Alida Paige
Alida Leanne
vote up1
I always wonder if it bothers me enough when a name has the word lie in its pronounciation. I haven’t thought about this prn, so thanks for mentioning it!Alida Leanne jumps out for me. Pretty!Faith is my no 1 name, Faith Alida makes me great combo :)
vote up1
I don’t love Jacob (probably due to someone I know named Jacob), but it’s not horrible. Alida is beautiful and I would pronounce it a-LEE-da.
vote up1
I like Alina better but Alida is cute too! Jacob is such a generic name where I live its not really anything special at all but in combination with Alida it becomes kinda cool!
vote up1
Perhaps quite agree with you. Perhaps I could use Jacob as middle name instead. Thanks for your opinion. Alina is pretty too, but doesn’t have the family connection.
vote up1
I like Jacob well enough but it's so popular and I know so many it has lost its appeal. Combined with Alida it does sound fresher.I love Alida. I'd definitely pronounce it a-LEE-da.
vote up1
Jacob isn't a bad name, though it's pretty overused now.Alida, on the other hand, is lovely. I would pronounce it ə-LEE-də. The two times I've seen it in real life, though, the women spelled their names as Aleida (same pronunciation). To me that looks like ə-LIE-də, but I guess it doesn't read that way to a lot of people.
vote up1
both nice and would be nice to use the family names - I'd pronounce Alida - a LEE da
vote up1
I really dislike the -ob part of Jacob, maybe it's because of the Jacob I went to school with who was always getting into trouble, but I quite like Jake, Jay and even Jayco, just not Jacob.I have known an Alita and an Eleeda. They have both been pronounced a-LEE-da, similar to "a litre of milk". I'm not a big fan.
vote up1
I'm not a fan of either name.I would pronounce Alida "a-LEE-da."
vote up1
Jacob is too Old Testament to me; it's over-used where I live, but that doesn't get rid of the image of an old man in white robes and sandals, toiling up a desert dune and shaking his fist at everyone who doesn't agree with him! And I don't enjoy Jake either.Alida happens every day where I live, but only in the Afrikaans community. Here, it's pronounced ahLIdah, with the middle syllable more like the word 'lid' than 'lead'. I quite like it, but not enough to use. If it were a family name, though, I'd use it as a mn without hesitation.
vote up1
It’s a popular name in South Africa with all ages?I hadn’t thought of your pronouciation, it makes sense though! Thanks for mentioning it!
vote up1
Since democracy, naming trends have changed a lot. This is, I think, because suddenly international TV was readily available, so the names used on particularly US entertainment channels were in the public eye. But what hasn't changed is the non-availability of any naming statistics at all in a useful and accessible form. And if they were, then the typically Indo-European and Muslim names used by white and Muslim parents wouldn't show up in a meaningful way, since black parents are increasingly likely to stay with their traditional names rather than doubling them up with Western names (Sondo Muriel would be Muriel among whites and Sondo among blacks for instance - this used to be a courtesy to people who couldn't pronounce names in African languages and, mostly, didn't try. Now, reasonably enough, it's sink or swim!) and the stats that are available show only African names. With no information on fashions, trends, even meanings ... so, it's very difficult to say a sensible word about naming practices. I know of a couple of Alida people, both of whom go by Lida, in their 30s but I have very little contact with younger people since we moved last year, so I'm guessing. I haven't been in a classroom for years!
vote up1
Jacob is fine but not really my style.
Alida (aLEEda) on the other hand I absolutely adore! I had a friend in kindergarten named this and I've loved it ever since. I would probably use it if I had a daughter right now.
vote up1
Thank you for your opinions!
vote up1