View Message

[Opinions] Gertrude & Maud
I know, I know, talking about names like Gertrude and Maud is far from unusual and the answers are always 50% "this is hideous and ought not be used" and 50% "this is a scrumptious name and anyone who doesn't admire it is pedestrian", so I shan't ask your opinion on them. But what I will ask is:
a) what middle names would you pair them with?
b) what first names would you pair them with?
c) which of the two do you prefer?
d) Maud or Maude?
e) Gertrude "Gertie" or Gertrude "Trudy"?
f) if you heard about two sisters named Gertrude and Maud (of any age), which one would you assume is older? Be it because the name feels more mature or just a hunch.Thanks!masculine list: https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/191050/124079
feminine list: https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/191050/124080

This message was edited 3/14/2021, 10:31 AM

Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

1) Gertrude Odette and Maude Rosetta
2) Bonnie-Rae Gertrude and Tamila Maude
3) prefer Gertrude
4) Maude
5) Neither, if I had to pick between the two: Trudy but prefer Truly or just Gertrude.
6) I would think Gertrude is older. Maude younger.
vote up1
Maude Rosetta is great! And wow, I love that Tamila is a variant of Tomila (from the Slavic element for "torture").

This message was edited 3/14/2021, 7:24 PM

vote up1
a) Gertrude Rosalind & Maud Etheldreda
b) Amanda Gertrude & Lilian Maud
c) Gertrude. It has always been a GP of mine. No strong feelings about Maud.
d) Maude looks more complete and elegant IMO.
e) Trudy. Gertie sounds like a modern nickname that feels a bit forced. Trudy comes more natural.
f) I'd assume Gertrude was older because it's more common (or more heard of) than Maud, and I tend to expect the older sibling to have the more common name (parents tend to be more liberal / wild with younger kids' names).
vote up1
I love both names! Gertrude is so beautiful.a) Gertrude Ianthe & Maud Elektra
b) Celestina Gertrude & Bibiana Maud
c) Gertrude
d) Maud
e) Trudy
f) If the sisters were elderly, I’d assume Gertrude to be the older one. If they were young girls born in the 21st century, I’d assume Maud to be older because it’s been embraced more by daring parents than Gertrude has.
vote up1
I really like Maud! I'm really coming around to it. It's such a tidy little name. a) Maud Christina and Gertrude Lilyb) oh that's tough, they look so sad in the shadows..... Winifred Maud & Lavender Gertrudec) I prefer Maudd) Ohh, another tough one..... Maud, I think?e) Trudy!!f) If they are young, I would guess that Maud is older. If they are old, then I would guess Gertrude is older. Gertrude does have a more serious, older vibe.
vote up1
I love Lily paired with Gertrude! It really livens it up.
vote up1
A. Gussie, Hassie, Tessie, something that ends in -ssie, Fanny
B. Marigold, Mary, Goldie, Gracie, Lucretia
C. Maybe Gertrude?
D. Maude
E. Trudy
F. Definitely Gertrude, it just seems more mature
vote up1