View Message

[Opinions] Lily vs Stella
Last name starts with Mel. I love both names, but think Lily is softer and flows better with last name. But I think Stella is more unique. Middle name would be Grace.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up2

Replies

Lily Grace is extremely boring and typical. Like Lily Rose. But it’s also very feminine and graceful. Stella Grace is also boring and makes Stella look extremely plain. But it’s not bad or anything.Lily Grace Mel- is nice. Stella Grace Mel is also nice. Stella is on the rise anyhow so it doesn’t make too much of a different. Lilies have a nice history and meaning if you’re into that kind of stuff. Stella is gorgeous, ethereal, and to echo the other people: Stella Mel doesn’t sound too good but it’s fine. Lily it is I guess.

This message was edited 4/22/2022, 4:23 PM

vote up1
I dislike both, Stella was cool before, but it's been thrown into the fires of overused OC names. Lily is annoying and whiny, and I can't imagine it on an adult.
vote up1
Much prefer Stella, find Lily a little inconsistent.
vote up1
I'd rather be Stella. My cousin has a daughter Lily, and I think it's sweet, but when I think about being called it, it seems too flimsy/delicate, so Stella seems more well-rounded and wearable.I think Stella Mel* sounds fine.

This message was edited 4/21/2022, 11:41 AM

vote up1
Lily is the name that I like more overall, but Stella Grace sounds better than Lily Grace.
Stella Grace Mel vs. Lily Grace Mel. I choose Stella Grace Mel. The middle name stops it from clashing with the surname. If it were just Lily Mel or Stella Mel, then Lily would win.

This message was edited 4/21/2022, 9:16 AM

vote up1
100% Lily, it’s softer, prettier, more down to earth. Stella is obnoxious. Plus STELla MEL- sounds kind of silly.
vote up3
While I don’t think Stella is obnoxious, I do agree that Stella Mel…. sounds a bit weird.
vote up1