View Message

[Opinions] Harlan and Roy
Both these names have been on my mind for a while. Roy was the name of my great uncle, short for Royal. He was quite a character. Harlan makes me think of the sci-fi author Harlan Ellison and a few people I know IRL. I've also come across the spelling Harlynn. Thoughts?https://quotidianpeace.wordpress.com/
vote up1

Replies

Roy is fine, if bland and dated.Harlan Ellison is one association, but I can't not think of Harlan Crow at the moment. Not a fan of the name at all.
vote up1
I also had a great uncle named Roy. He was in the same prison with Charles Manson, for a while.Anyway, I like Royal, and Roy has a certain charm. Harlan is very country bumpkin to me, because it just sounds that way. Not the worst thing in the world, I just picture a dude shucking corn when I hear it.
vote up1
That's why I like it. Harlan makes me think of a sun-beaten old farmer, calloused hands, leaning back in a chair with a cup of coffee. Old farmers are the best. Best jokes, best hugs, biggest hearts.
vote up1
Love Harlan, not crazy about Roy
vote up1
Roy is ok, don't really like Harlan
vote up1
Harlan doesn't happen where I live. Roy does: including one of my brothers-in-law, Roy Fraser LN. Scottish ancestry, and by a happy accident, he is also a redhead. I love both of his names.
vote up1
Hi! Both Roy and Harlan have a Medieval vibe in my opinion. Roy is so short but full of history and links that are Norman and Celtic. I love its regal meaning but also its rough form Ruadh that means "red".Harlan: as I live in Italy the only Harlan I came across is a fictional character... Sir Harlan of Pennytree, hedge knight created by George R.R. Martin in the 'Ice & Fire' Universe.I actually like them and I'd enjoy coming across one of them in the Anglosphere.

This message was edited 6/17/2023, 11:42 AM

vote up1
It's amazing to see how differently names are seen I didn't know a lot of Harlans until I moved to Midwest USA. I've met a handful now, all 80+.Roy is also fairly common in the US, 50+. It, too, seems to be more common in the Midwest.The idea that they are Medieval would never occur to me!
vote up1