View Message

I don't like either, but I prefer Reginald. Reggie is better than Arnie, that's for sure.

I love Reginald, but I'm not too big on Armold.

I love Reginald, Reg and Reggie. I pick that one.

I like both, although Reginald I would only use as a mn (and it’s a very good mn at that) but Arnold is actually on my short list, I think it’s friendly and homey sounding.

I love both, but Arnold was my grandpa's name, so I have a soft spot for it.

Neither

Reginald for sure. Arnold always sounded a bit silly to me.

I wouldn't use either, or expect to see them in use; Reginald is far more appealing than Arnold, and Reg or even Reggie wouldn't be bad.

Don't like either

Reginald. Reggie is a much cooler nickname than Arnie. And Arnold reminds me of Schwarzenegger. I have no obvious associations with Reginald, so it’s open to whatever.