View Message

Jemima
Too racist? What is your impression of this name? Willoughby wolloughby willina, an elephant sat on Billina.
Willoughby wolloughby wirfak, an elephant sat on Mirfak.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I love the name Jemima and have loved it since I discovered the musical CATS. In Sweden it has no bad connotations (but it's rare, I've only seen it used by deeply religious families) and would be totally usable.
I know that when CATS moved to Broadway, the character Jemima was renamed SILLABUB, but I don't know about later productions. When I saw it in London, there was a Jemima among the characters.

This message was edited 7/14/2015, 12:54 PM

vote up1
I'm Australian, so I don't make the connection at all.But isn't using it helping dispel that racist stereotype? I think Jemima is gorgeous, and I love the nn Jem. It's on my short list!Jemima Ruby
Jemima Carys
Jemima Opal
Jemima Eloise
Jemima Cecily
Jemima Lucy
Jemima Claire
Jemima Sylvie
vote up1
As you will see from my post below, I love the name Jemima. Here in Australia there is absolutely no racist links to the name, which I am thoroughly happy with. I just think it's a beautiful name with a sweet vintage feel.
vote up1
I think it's an ugly name. It has nothing to do with race as far as I'm concerned. It just makes a very unpleasant, repetitive sound. It doesn't even look good written. Say it alound, repeatedly and you'll probably get what I'm saying.
vote up1
Yeah, the "mammy" implications are too much for me to get into it. I don't like my names to be reminiscent of racist imagery. Worse yet if I picked a name already knowing as much. I remember once I objected to a hypothetical sibset Joseph and Magda because it was the name of Joseph Goebbels and his wife. People replied that surely no one would think of this and people don't know that, etc. Well, I thought it. I'm a person of average intelligence and curiosity, so if it's a fact that I can recall I can't be the only one. I think similarly about the connotations with Jemima; maybe it doesn't occur to everyone, but it does to enough people that I wouldn't go there.
vote up1
I remember that. :-) I knocked them off my list.I actually removed Joseph off my list completely because of my last name. Joseph Surname is the ignoble patriarch of an American "dynasty." Most people wouldn't get it, but I get it and that's enough.
vote up1
Most people wouldn't get it? I think a lot of people would. :/
vote up1
If Joseph is off the list can Magda come back? :-) I like Magda very much; I felt bad making an argument against it.
vote up1
Unfortunately, no. :-) My cousin used Magdalene. What's funny is she had Miriam on her list but decided to go with Magdalene.
vote up1
DH and I absolutely love Jemima but would never use it due to its negative associations. Fortunately for us, there's always the opportunity to use it for future pets. :-)
vote up1
Why is it racist? All I think of is Jemima Puddleduck.
vote up1
Seeing as I have never heard of that, no I don't think Jemima is racist.
vote up1
I don't really like the sound of it, but I think it would be perfectly usable, particularly where I live.
vote up1
I'ts really pretty and I love the meaning, but yeah, too associated with racist mammy stereotypes for me to find it usable.
vote up1
"Too racist?" took my by surprise and I had to think for a moment what you were referring to. I've met a handful of girls named Jemima and Aunt Jemima has never crossed my mind. At most, I think of Jemima Puddleduck and Chitty Bang Bang. I can't use it, and that does make me kind of sad.
vote up1
I think it's a lot more associated with Aunt Jemima in the US than in the UK.
vote up1
I imagine so. I think the only reason I've heard of Aunt Jemima is through being interested in names.
vote up1
I've actually met a Jemima over here who was mixed race. I don't know exactly how problematic it would be in the USA but it's fine here.
vote up1
I think it's a lovely name, and I have always thought it was daring, but ultimately innocuous.
vote up1
I don't think so. I think of Jemima Kirke from Girls. When I heard it on her I didn't even make the connection about "Aunt". I think it's usable.
vote up1
I love it, but in the US, it's too racist. There's a reason that in the US, it's not even in the top thousand, and the last time it was was 1893.
vote up1
Pancakes and puddle-ducks. The name is just too goofy for me to be able to picture it on a real, ordinary person. Even for a storybook, it's just totally comical.
vote up1
All I can think of is Aunt Jemima Pancakes and that creepy commercial for them :/ I can kind of see how it could be cute but I can't like it :S
vote up1
Ah! "too racist"... I wouldn't have ever thought of it as racist unless it was a stereotyped character in book. In fact, I think using it combats the racist vibe some people see in it. I thinks it's a fantastic name and totally works. Plus, it has a modern nickname in "Jem" built right in!
I actually could totally see this as a hipster name.
"These are my children, Atticus, Jemima and Edie."
vote up1
Jemima and Edie would be adorable for sisters! But apparently I do quite like the "hipster" names! ;)
vote up1
I read yesterday that Atticus Finch is portrayed as racist in Go Set a Watchman. I'm kind of sad about that.
vote up1
Ditto
vote up1
Editing this out.Sorry. I posted about it in the Lounge, so go there. :P

This message was edited 7/13/2015, 10:11 AM

vote up1
Damn!I didn't know Jem was dead. My copy of the book came today, but I missed the delivery.
vote up1
I think the name Atticus is far better suited to an antagonist.
vote up1
Objectively, I think you might be right, but it's been associated with such a positive figure for so long in my mind that I find it difficult to separate the two.
vote up1
I agree. The name Atticus makes me think of someone who stands up for what is right. It's hard to look at it objectively, at least for me.
vote up1
Oh, the pseudo-innate responses ingrained in us during middle school Lit class. ;)
Atticus always had such a harsh sound to me, like Gattica.
vote up1