View Message

Elin
I've made the decision to take Arabella out of my top 25 girls' names. It's in the top 100 now and since I already have Araminta on my list, I feel like I won't miss it too much. I'm thinking of replacing it with Elin. My Welsh family and friends pronounce it as AY-lin, whereas the English would pronounce it as EL-in (Ellen here is more like EL-ən, for reference). I would probably say EL-in but I don't think AY-lin is too different to cause confusion.The name would also work to honour my mother. What are your thoughts on Elin? Thanks!
Jagoda
Top 25: https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/136993/97278
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I'm in the U.S. and I have no issue with ay-lin. I wouldn't pronounce Elin as Ellen.I love it.Edited to add: I'm in an area that has a Scandinavian heritage and if I came across Elin I'd pronounce it the Swedish way first.

This message was edited 12/31/2017, 4:11 PM

vote up1
I just wrote the name down for two of my nieces, aged 11 and 14. Both said they would get the ay-lin pronunciation. Neither saw it as a kreativ version of Ellen.
vote up1
That's really great, thank you!
vote up1
No problem.Note: They are in DC, which is a pretty international city, similar to London.
vote up1
I went to grad school with a Welsh Elin. It's nice, though it looks a little odd visually as opposed to Eileen for instance.
vote up1
Thanks! It does look a little odd, I know.
vote up1
EL in and EH lin sound the same when I say them. :) I've always liked it: neat and light on its feet, unlike lumbering Arabella! I know lots of Elins of all ages and a few Elens too - popular name in N Wales.eta for random nerdery: like Alys/Alis & Alice, it was also a common medieval spelling of Helen.

This message was edited 12/30/2017, 5:06 AM

vote up1
I thought it might be pretty popular in Wales but I hadn’t checked and I’ve never met anyone with the name! I didn’t know it was a medieval spelling of Helen, though - I guess because H’s weren’t really pronounced? Thanks!
vote up1
Elin is non uncommon here (Australia) and it seems to be a mix of Ee-lin and eh-linA friends kid is Elina (dad is Finnish) and it's eh-lin-uhIt's pretty, I like either pronunciation.
vote up1
Oh, Elina is nice with that pronunciation! Thanks!
vote up1
It's actually super confusing because he is Finnish but his wife is not, and they prnounce the name slightly different, so I sorta avoid saying it..
My husband can't say it at all.
vote up1
I love it! I much prefer the pronunciation Ee-lin, but I don't think EL-in would be mispronounced too much even in the US. I don't like AY-lin quite as much.
vote up1
I'm not convinced EE-lin is legit, but in any case it sounds too similar to Ealing, a borough of London, for me to use. Thanks.
vote up1
In Germany, Elin would be pronounced as follows: EH-lin
Quite contrary to Aylin or Ilean: IE-linPersonally, I like the extraordinary Elif much better.
vote up1
Elif is sweet, I had actually forgotten about it's existence. It wouldn't work to honour but I'll add it onto my long list!
vote up1
Well, I asked about this name before, and people told me they'd heard it pronounced EE-lin, while I was pronouncing it EL-in, lol. Anyway, I like it fine. I think it's simple and pretty and I like it a lot more than Arabella, which is poofy and fluffy and sugary and yuck (sorry).I also agree with you that correcting the pronunciation of a name takes one second, and that it's not a big deal. My name is fairly common, it's a name everyone in the US has heard of, but I have to correct people all the time because of that one extra letter. Use what you like, and teach the kid how to politely correct people. No big thing.

This message was edited 12/29/2017, 8:39 AM

vote up1
The EE-lin pronunciation confuses me, I wasn’t sure if I was missing something. I can’t count the amount of times I’ve had to correct people on the pronunciation of my name, and sometimes I don’t even bother, so I was also surprised on the fixation on it here for that reason!I don’t mind you insulting Arabella at all, haha. Thanks!

This message was edited 12/29/2017, 9:40 AM

vote up1
Further clarification... for anyone who doesn't believe the AY-lin pronunciation isn't a big deal, here it is said aloud: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAWpRlW6zwo
vote up1
That's not AY-lin to me but EH-lin. EH-lin is also the only pronunciation of the name here in Sweden.
I've seen AY- used before to explain a pronunciation that should be EH (like E in Emily). I don't know if they sound the same in English but to me they are two distinct sounds that are not interchangeable.https://forvo.com/search/Elin/ETA: I replied because I can hear that the woman who is saying Elin is Swedish and I just wanted to point out that to me it's EH-lin and not AY-lin and I'm not quite sure how it's different from EL-in which you say is the English way to say the name.

This message was edited 12/29/2017, 9:33 AM

vote up1
You can hear the difference between the Swedish and Welsh pronunciation
vote up1
They’re pretty similar in Welsh, when I say them in a Welsh accent I can’t tell the difference, but they are different in an English accent. I just didn’t know how else to transcribe the Welsh pronunciation. I thought the pronunciation was just an interesting note, because it isn’t the same as Ellen here and I like that Welsh family and friends say it in the Welsh way. I had been wondering about the Swedish pronunciation as it’s a bit of a dream of mine to move to Sweden, so thanks for sharing that!
vote up1
Yes, I’d rather see Elin than Arabella. So many Welsh names are so unfamiliar and pretty. Araminta is nicer than Arabella to me. Arabella is slightly over-the-top.
vote up1
It's pretty familiar here, but I see what you mean! Arabella is an old favourite of mine so I took a long time to let it go, but now is the time I think.
vote up1
In the US, Elin is exclusively associated with Tiger Woods's wife or ex-wife or whatever she is now. Her name is pronounced EE-lyn.
I think Ellen would probably be a less confusing; if you want the Ay-lin sound, Aylin might work better.
vote up1
Ellen takes away the honouring aspect. As I’ve said the name works here. I just wanted some general thoughts on it without getting into the pronunciation issues, which are non-existent here.
vote up1
I know an Elin who pronounces it EE-lin - she is from Sweden. I definitely don't like it with an Ellen pronunciation, and don't feel AY-lin is too intuitive. But I feel it's a name that is setting yourself up for it being mispronounced. Not a fan.
vote up1
agree:)
vote up1
You can agree butIt works here. The British English and Welsh pronunciations are very very similar when heard. It doesn't matter to me that it isn't as intuitive in the US, even slightly. I just wanted to know what people thought of it in the context that it works here.
vote up1
To be clearThis name works where I live. People either know it or can get to grips with it easily. I was hoping people would be able to give their opinions on it once they knew how it would be pronounced where I live and would be able to look past it not working where they live. The AY-lin pronunciatjon is basically EL-in with a welsh accent. It isn’t that big of a deal.
vote up1
Ok, you don't need to freak out on everybody. You asked for opinions on a name, and unfortunately people's cultures and cultural predispositions affect how they see a name. We live in a very international society, and having foreign perspectives on a name is something you should be grateful for, not angry about. The fact that your pronunciation doesn't work in the US could mean Elin would face difficulty if she were ever to travel here, or move here, or interact with people from here. So, my opinion on the AY-lin pronunciation: You either sound like you're saying "Hey, Lynn!" and trying to get Lynn's attention or it sounds like "ailing" like you have an ailment. I also feel the fact that Elin's English and Welsh relatives would pronounce her name differently to be something to avoid, perhaps it would be a name better left for the middle-name slot.
vote up1
I'm not freaking out on anyone, but thanks for misreading my normal tone. It takes a second to correct the pronunciation of a name. I am not actively encouraging the Welsh pronunciation. I have Welsh family and friends who will use it regardless of whether I do or not. I have American friends. I live in the most multicultural city in the world. None of them would struggle.Again, they do not sound different enough to be confusing. I have heard it said in both accents.I don't know how much clearer I can be before people stop repeating the same thing I addressed in my op, and in basically all of my replies.

This message was edited 12/29/2017, 8:03 AM

vote up1
Hi !!!!If it is honouring so use it wothout problem!I personally think it is quite weak.
I much prefer the Modern Greek form Eleni.
vote up1
Unfortunately, Eleni takes away the honouring aspect, but I do like it!
vote up1
I like it, but I’ve always heard it pronounced EE-lin. The pronunciation ambiguity could be seen as a problem.
vote up1
Please see my response to Serel Channah. Thanks.
vote up1
I like it as EL-in, though pronunciation issues mean I prefer Ellen. I would pronounce both Ellen and Elin EL-in. I've never met an Ellen who said EL-ən.I don't care for AY-lin much. It sounds like a tryndee creation (Ailynn or something) and is not very intuitive from Elin. Ellen/Elin is fairly dated here but I think it would be delightfully refreshing on a little girl. I'd be a bit sad if she became one of ten zillion little girls called Ella or Ellie, though.
vote up1
Quote I've never met an Ellen who said EL-ən.
Then you're clearly not from the UK. Neither EL-in or AY-lin would cause an issue here.
vote up1
Guilty as charged. If you live where people are familiar with Elin, I like it (but only as as EL-in).
vote up1
As I said, my Welsh family and friends would pronounce it the Welsh way, which is AY-lin. I wouldn't correct that as I'm English and Welsh.
vote up1
Ah, I misunderstood. I thought you meant you'd pick one pronunciation. Getting AY-lin from Welsh speakers would make me not use Elin, personally, but if you wouldn't mind it's a lovely name.
vote up1
No worries, sorry I wasn't clearer, I tried to explain it as best I could!
vote up1