View Message

Maisie, Aggie, and Frankie (m)
WDYT of these names for girls?If you had to rank them best to worst, how would you rank them? **Starfish and coffee, maple syrup and jam/Butterscotch clouds, a tangerine, and a side order of ham**
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Aggie is kind of cute yet not too frivolous. Enough like Maggie that it could grow on me if I knew one. Though slightly ruined by my having been exposed to Texas A&M (and other ag universities) being called "Aggies."Maisie is Mazey ... sticky-saccharine, sloppy farmgirl, from-a-twee-book name. Frankie isn't a name I've ever seen as a woman's name until the 2000s (and even then, as a film character). If I had ever seen it IRL I might not hate it so much ... but as it is, I find it irritatingly synthetic and perkie-chirpie Hollywood, like Piper or Coco, trying to be a character. I'd use Fran for Frances / Francine instead.

This message was edited 2/2/2020, 1:15 AM

vote up1
B.'s sister is named Frankie, and coincidentally right after reading your post I went to Facebook and saw a post in my widows group from a woman named Frankie. I still hate the name, though.
vote up1
Maisie I really like a lot. Aggie and Frankie I can do without. Neither appeals to me at all. Best to worst would be Maisie, Aggie and Frankie.
vote up1
Maisie first. Not bad on the whole, and May is a good nn.
Aggie: nn only; quite friendly.
Frankie: awful, whether as a nn or as a full name.
vote up1
I really like Maisie. It feels very nicknamey though so I'd only use it with another fuller name to fall back on, but I'm not sure what that name would be.Aggie and Frankie are also nickname names. I don't mind Aggie, but I'm not a fan of Frankie. It just reminds me of teen greaser gangs with their leather jackets and switchblades and stuff lol
vote up1
1. Maisie
2. Frankie
3. AggieI like Maisie but it is probably too cutesy and childish. I dislike Frankie personally but I get the appeal of it so I've ranked it higher than Aggie which I neither like nor see the appeal of.
vote up1
Assuming they're full names:1. Frankie (because I love Frances and it's less dated on a girl)
2. Maisie
3. AggieBut I prefer Agatha "Aggie" or Agnes "Aggie" to Maisie. I only like Maisie if her full name is Mairead and she goes by Mairead when she grows up.

This message was edited 2/1/2020, 1:03 AM

vote up1
Maisie, then Frankie, then Aggie.
vote up1
Maisie first, Aggie second and then Frankie
vote up1
Maisie is ok, dont like the others
vote up1
Don't love any really. Frankie I think is awful, I don't see the appeal at all. Preference
1. Maisie
2. Aggie
3. Frankie
vote up1
As nicknames only they're fine. I don't like them for formal first names.Best to worst: Maisie, Frankie, Aggie.
vote up1
Love em all. They're all very poodle-skirt.Frankie is the best, then Maisie, then Aggie.
vote up1
Hi !!!!1 Maisie because it reminds me amazing and it's youthful and cheerful2 Aggie because it reminds me Agatha and it's similar to Iggy that I like for a boy.3 Frankie nothing special.
vote up1
They're bad.Ranking:1. Maisie
2. Frankie
3. AggieBut they're all awful.
vote up1
I like Agnes and Frances, but not Aggie and Frankie. Maisie is ok but quite popular here.
vote up1
I like them. Frankie has a 1920s feel to it, sister to Maxine. Aggie is familiar, and Maisie reminds me of the children's books and the fictional detective Maisie Dobbs.Frankie, Aggie, Maisie
vote up1
I don't like any of them. They all sound childish and unpleasant to me. Frankie > Maisie > Aggie.
vote up1