I like
Hayley >
Haley >
Hailey
I have never met a real life
Hayley. I knew someone who named her daughter
Hayley, but the child was stillborn. I've never met anyone else with this name, and I only know
Hayley Mills as a famous namesake.
In my region
Amanda and
Jessica are from an earlier popularity period than
Hayley.
With all that, it would actually be fresh new name in my region.