I pronounce both
Finlay and
Finley as FIN-lee. Endings such as -ey and -ay can definitely be confusing. :b Take the words "valley" and "they", for instance. But I've never heard
Finlay pronounced as FIN-lay, personally. As an example, the name
Lindsey can be spelled as
Lindsey or
Lindsay, but (as far as I know) both are pronounced the same: LIND-see / LIND-zee.
~
Heather~
