New Post
Search
Help[Facts] Re: Additional Info About Girl Name, Jubilee...
in reply to a message by Sabertooth
Actually, its not over the top because all of the information relates to its etymology whereas your submission had a lot of erroneous information. Its okay to be wordy, as long as the "wordy" is purposeful.
"And expressing my ideas within the article's established format was unacceptable, too?"
I'm really confused at what you are trying to say here. If you are referring to adding opinion to a submission, then yes, opinion is unacceptable in a submission. A submission is meant to highlight facts about a name.
"And expressing my ideas within the article's established format was unacceptable, too?"
I'm really confused at what you are trying to say here. If you are referring to adding opinion to a submission, then yes, opinion is unacceptable in a submission. A submission is meant to highlight facts about a name.
1
Replies
"If you are referring to adding opinion to a submission, then yes, opinion is unacceptable in a submission. A submission is meant to highlight facts about a name."
No, I'm not referring to adding opinion.
It is the intense effort to obfuscate the eponym that has me confused.
No, I'm not referring to adding opinion.
It is the intense effort to obfuscate the eponym that has me confused.
This message was edited 8/6/2014, 4:05 AM
1
"It is the intense effort to obscure the eponym that has me confused."
Thats exactly why I am not putting more information about "year of jubilee" in the entry. It obscures the actual, factual meaning of the name. Not everyone named Jubilee is named after the year of Jubilee, nor is every Christian or Jew named Jubilee named after the year of Jubilee. Its actually the opposite. The year of jubilee simply uses the word Jubilee which has its own line up of etymology. Putting that into the submission as the main "meaning" of the name is not factual.
Does this edit make you happier?
"Derives from Ancient Greek #ἰωβηλαῖος# (#iōbēlaîos#, 'of a jubilee'), from #ἰώβηλος# (#iṓbēlos#, 'jubilee'), from Hebrew #יובל# (#yobēl#/#yovēl#, 'ram, ram's horn; jubilee' in reference to the year of jubilee)."
Thats exactly why I am not putting more information about "year of jubilee" in the entry. It obscures the actual, factual meaning of the name. Not everyone named Jubilee is named after the year of Jubilee, nor is every Christian or Jew named Jubilee named after the year of Jubilee. Its actually the opposite. The year of jubilee simply uses the word Jubilee which has its own line up of etymology. Putting that into the submission as the main "meaning" of the name is not factual.
Does this edit make you happier?
"Derives from Ancient Greek #ἰωβηλαῖος# (#iōbēlaîos#, 'of a jubilee'), from #ἰώβηλος# (#iṓbēlos#, 'jubilee'), from Hebrew #יובל# (#yobēl#/#yovēl#, 'ram, ram's horn; jubilee' in reference to the year of jubilee)."
This message was edited 8/6/2014, 2:23 AM
1
-- Does this edit make you happier? --
This conversation reminds me of a "Simpsons" clip, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FPgtsohaIs
This conversation reminds me of a "Simpsons" clip, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FPgtsohaIs
1