New Post
Search
Help
ArchivesRe: Surname in my family, where does it come from???
in reply to a message by Jim Young
The region of Macedonia in Greece didn't have a Slavo-Macedonian minority for quite a while... In 1926 for example, the place was 88% Greek, and it only increased since.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_(Greece)#Demographics
Moreover, the particular town Kastoria doesn't have any Macedonian minority that I know of - of course I could be wrong, but geographical proximity to a country/language doesn't guarantee the existence of a minority, and I think this is the case here. :)
Anyway, after, and during the Balkan and World Wars, many Balkanic countries engaged in population exchanges in order to "purify" their territory, and Greece was definitely not an exception. One thing is for certain - nothing is certain in the Balkans! ;)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macedonia_(Greece)#Demographics
Moreover, the particular town Kastoria doesn't have any Macedonian minority that I know of - of course I could be wrong, but geographical proximity to a country/language doesn't guarantee the existence of a minority, and I think this is the case here. :)
Anyway, after, and during the Balkan and World Wars, many Balkanic countries engaged in population exchanges in order to "purify" their territory, and Greece was definitely not an exception. One thing is for certain - nothing is certain in the Balkans! ;)
1
Replies
Hey,
Sorry to say, but I agree with YesIAm. Kastoria is purely a Greek town, and sure, its only natural that two bordering countries, at their borders may have some populations that speak different languages. All of Greece for example, has many Albanian residents (illegal and not)., but that doesn't in any way lessen the Greek identity of Greece.
As for the name, its wrong to try to hog a term that refers to a whole geographical area that in includes three different nations, and make it refer to one. Macedonia is an ancient name, and as for its origins and meaning, it is Greek. See, the problem isn't with FYROM wanting to have a part in the term, because yes, geographically, their country is a significant part of Macedonia. The problem is when they want to use the name exclusively for themselves, when it rightfully applies to a region.
This also causes misunderstandings and confusion (for example as demonstrated in the above posts).
Sorry to say, but I agree with YesIAm. Kastoria is purely a Greek town, and sure, its only natural that two bordering countries, at their borders may have some populations that speak different languages. All of Greece for example, has many Albanian residents (illegal and not)., but that doesn't in any way lessen the Greek identity of Greece.
As for the name, its wrong to try to hog a term that refers to a whole geographical area that in includes three different nations, and make it refer to one. Macedonia is an ancient name, and as for its origins and meaning, it is Greek. See, the problem isn't with FYROM wanting to have a part in the term, because yes, geographically, their country is a significant part of Macedonia. The problem is when they want to use the name exclusively for themselves, when it rightfully applies to a region.
This also causes misunderstandings and confusion (for example as demonstrated in the above posts).
1
Very well put :-)
1