This is a list of professional athletes who belong to the Halls of Fame for baseball, ice hockey, basketball and (American) football. If shown, the year indicates when the individual was inaugurated.
| Name | Details | Total |
|---|
| Wilkes | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Wilkins | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Wilkinson | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Williams | 4 baseball, 2 basketball, 1 football | 7 |
| Willis | 1 baseball, 1 football | 2 |
| Wilson | 2 baseball, 2 football, 2 ice hockey | 6 |
| Winfield | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Winslow | 1 football | 1 |
| Winter | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Wojciechowicz | 1 football | 1 |
| Wolf | 1 football | 1 |
| Wood | 1 football | 1 |
| Woodard | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Wooden | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Woodson | 2 football | 2 |
| Wootten | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Worsley | 1 ice hockey | 1 |
| Worters | 1 ice hockey | 1 |
| Worthy | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Wright | 2 baseball, 1 football | 3 |
| Wynn | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Yakushev | 1 ice hockey | 1 |
| Yao | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Yardley | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Yary | 1 football | 1 |
| Yastrzemski | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Young | 1 baseball, 3 football | 4 |
| Youngblood | 1 football | 1 |
| Youngs | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Yount | 1 baseball | 1 |
| Yow | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Yzerman | 1 ice hockey | 1 |
| Zimmerman | 1 football | 1 |
| Zollner | 1 basketball | 1 |
| Zubov | 1 ice hockey | 1 |