I don't think the formal name decision should revolve around a nickname, since the nickname may never be used, and then you've just settled on a formal name. I think nicknames should be left up to the child, and not planned by the parent(s). I'd scrap the whole idea. I don't think
Andrew or
Andrea are at all popular. I do like
Andrew.
The greatest single human gift - the ability to chase down our dreams. - "Artificial Intelligence: AI"