Take two names from each group until there is only one name remaining. You may play as many times as you want as long as you don't play off your own post. (Basically you can't play two times in a row.) Have fun!
DH:
First name:
Jonathan,
Silas,
Amos,
Henry,
Owen,
Joseph,
Samuel,
Daniel,
Charles,
Peter,
Wilbur,
Arthur,
Julian
Taking:
Middle name:
Caleb,
Cyrus,
Paul,
Anthony,
Christian,
Daveth,
Gregory,
Horatio,
Frederick,
Landon,
Blaine,
Montgomery,
Topher
Taking: