Jackson Hawthorne,
Charles Hawthorne and
James Hawthorne all strike me as being terribly handsome and distinguished.
Parker Hawthorne is too much surname-name in one name for me
Dante Hawthorne is not bad, but it's total "I'm cooler than you and way into literature" in-your-face overkill. I might go with
Virgil Hawthorne, though - THAT is drop-dead awesome.
I don't care for
Andrew, it's just not my thing, so I can't give any feedback on it.