I like it, but don't love it. Even before it got trendy, it always reminded me of "mealy," and I hated that. Now, of course, it's with
Eleanor and
Abigail as ridiculously-popular-names-from-19th-century brought back.
Amelia Poppy Ruth is *nice.* That's about all I can say. It's very pretty, but it feels kind of blah because of the huge wave of similar names cropping up. I think if I had seen this five years ago, I would have thought it was super original and really cool, but I can't really say that anymore. :/ I'm sorry!
Milly and
Amy are cute, but I'd use
Melia or
Mia, personally.