View Message

[Opinions] Brooke or Paige?
If you had to choose between Brooke and Paige for a girl, which one and why? Which one is more common where you live? You can change spellings.And which combo would you choose? Could you rate or comment on the combos?Paige Louise (thought of it today and I think it's kind of cute)
Paige Louise Elizabeth or Paige Elizabeth Louise (Elizabeth is a variant of a family name)
Paige Elsa Louise
Paige Elsa (Elsa is a family name)
Paige Noelle
Paige AnnabelleLouise is the middle name of my boyfriend's mom, but it has really grown on me, not only because it could be a family name (if I marry him).Brooke Annabelle
Brooke Estella
Brooke Marie (boring but I love Marie)
Brooke Eloisa
Brooke Aquinnahfeel free to suggest combos
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Ugh to both. I'd say Paige is better, though, because I think my dislike of it is just due to knowing a really bratty Paige when I was a kid. Brooke's probably more popular here, and it sounds trashy to me.Paige Louise - there's something strangely matchy about it, and I can't place it
Paige Elizabeth Louise is alright.
Paige Elsa has weird flow to me.
Paige Noelle is pretty good.
Paige Annabelle - I think the short and cute quality of Paige contrasts badly against the extravagant elegance of Annabelle. Noelle has elegance, but it's simple enough that they don't clash, they just balance.Brooke Annabelle is the best of the Brooke combos, imo.
vote up1
I'd pick Brooke. I think it's a great name! Paige Elsa Louise & Brooke Eloisa are gorgeous combos!
vote up1
aw Paige LouiseI don't particularly like how it looks, but it sounds reeeeaally cute. Especially as a double name.I've known both one Brooke and one Paige, so I'd say they are pretty equal in popularity where I live.If you like Marie, Marie Paige would be pretty dang adorable too.
vote up1
I used to like the sound of Paige until I really focused on its meaning and didn't care for it. I mean, I realize Brooke (brook) is a noun and a nature reference, however, it's picturesque and tranquil and has a lovely sound and represents all of these good associations to me so I'd go with that. Of your combos, I like Brooke Estella best, however, I'd recommend Brooke Louise Elisabeth to incorporate Louise and Elsa or even Elsa "Brooke" Louise although I know some people don't like going by the mn.
vote up1
I'd go with Brooke, hands down. Paige is okay, but i know several (all born between 1994-1996), it seems a bit dated to me. I do like Page as a middle name for a boy though. I know one Brooke, she's 2 or 3 I can't remember and I know of no other's, it's really not common here. I'd choose Brooke AnnabelleThe Brooke I know is Brooke Marie
vote up1
I prefer Paige. It sounds crisper and more interesting to me than Brooke. Brooke is more popular where I live than Paige (but Brooke has been completely eclipsed in local popularity by the gagworthy Brooklyn).
Paige Louise: (5) I've grown to love Louise, but I'm still underwhelmed by it as a MN.
Paige Louise Elizabeth: (5)
Paige Elizabeth Louise: (5) This is the one I'd pick if I had to use one.
Paige Elsa Louise: (4)
Paige Elsa: (5)
Paige Noelle: (5) This would be my second pick.
Paige Annabelle: (0) "page an' a bell" Brooke Annabelle: (1) "brook an' a bell" I'll give it a 1 because it doesn't leap out at me quite the way Paige Annabel does.
Brooke Estella: (8) This is my favorite combo listed. It makes me picture the Milky Way, or a river of stars.
Brooke Marie: (4)
Brooke Eloisa: (6)
Brooke Aquinnah: (6/7) This is interesting. I like it.Overall, I prefer your Brooke combos.
vote up1
Brooke. No contest.Brooke Louise or Brooke Estella could work.
vote up1
Paige Annabelle.nz
vote up1
I'd go for Paige any time, because where I live, Brooke sounds like the word for trousers and underpants.Paige Louise is really distinguished. Paige Elizabeth Louise would get your Elsa variant in very neatly. And what about Paige Marie?
vote up1