View Message

[Opinions] Catherine or Katherine?
Tell me why
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Definitely Catherine. It's gorgeous and looks so much better in my opinion.
vote up1
Catherine. It's served me well as my name for nearly 30 years. :)
vote up1
Catherine.The C version isn't used as much as Katherine. But if I had to use a K, I'd use Katharine.
vote up1
Thanks for the responses!They were interesting to read. I love the name Katherine and as I age (hah!) it seems that the K spelling just seems common while the C is softer and somehow more sophisticated.
vote up1
It was the opposite for me. I'm guessing that the popular spelling of Katherine is about to switch back to Catherine - so that it's fresh again. Perhaps Cathy as the nn will come back Now that Katie and Kate are so common.
vote up1
Man, I hope not. I've always hated Cathy/Kathy.
vote up1
it's inevitableI'm not a fan of Kathy either but it will come back.
vote up1
NOOOOOO, WHYYYYY?!?!?!?!?
vote up1
Ditto. I've let it slide when people have called me "Katie," but I can't tolerate Cathy. Yuck.
vote up1
I completely agree about the switch back. Katie and Kate is getting too common.
vote up1
Katherine.I think it comes from the fact, that in Denmark most Katherine names, ass variations is with a 'K' and not a 'C'. I.e. you mostly see 'K' than 'C'. I'm just used to it and it also makes more sense to me in a way, that Katherine looks more 'complete' to me than Catherine. I don't know how to explain it than that.I do like Catherine, but Katherine a whole lot more.

This message was edited 9/9/2013, 5:23 AM

vote up1
Catherine looks as if it should sound French. Katherine is the default, I suppose. Katharine looks better to me, probably because K is a less common letter than C in normal use, so it has a pleasantly "different" air.
vote up1
If I had had had to choose one, I think I'd pick Catherine in the end. Katherine is sleeker, smarter, more modern and fresh, and so for that reason I'd probably settle on musty, mushy, meek-martyr Catherine. She's like a shy little dumpling, and I admit I find the nickname Cathy on a toddler to be damn cute. And the Kitty pet name seems sweeter somehow when it comes via the Cat- route rather than Kat.
vote up1
Catherine with a 'C'. I just like the look of Cs better than Ks really. But I also like the associations with St Catherine of Siena and St Catherine of Alexandria. Yeah...I'm an atheist but I guess you can take the girl out of Catholicism but the Catholicism is never completely out of the girl :p
vote up1
Personally, Katharine is my favorite. Between those two Katherine. Catherine seems grandmotherly, Katherine has more attitude. While I find Katharine has attitude and elegance.
vote up1
Katherine.I'm wondering how many people so far have replied: "because Catherine with a 'C' is so smug"? (OMG I just checked and no one has said it yet! If this was on the lounge, you would have gotten a bunch of Anne of Avonlea responses.) Honestly, Catherine with a "C" seems too Catholic, too goody goody, too rounded. Plus, Katherine with a "K" is the only "K" name I like. Plus it gives you Kate without a stretch. Cate is dumb. I'd assume it's short for Caitlin, and ew.

This message was edited 9/8/2013, 5:21 PM

vote up1
"Honestly, Catherine with a "C" seems too Catholic, too goody goody, too rounded."Maybe that's why it fits me so well. ;)
vote up1
I prefer Catherine, probably because that is the name of one of my friends. I also think it looks better.
vote up1
I like Katherine and Catherine equally (I prefer Katharine/Catharine) but I prefer Kate, Katie, Kathy, and Kat to Cate, Catie, Cathy, and Cat. So Katherine.
vote up1
Katherine, although I prefer it spelled Katharine.
vote up1
Depends. My dd is Katherine (Kate) although I actually prefer the look of Catherine. I'm not wild about Cate although I know in the UK it's not uncommon for Catherines to spell Kate this way so I could have done that as well. I'm all about continuity so that's why I chose Katherine for my dd. As a mn, I do prefer Catherine.
vote up1
Katherine. I just prefer the look of the K and I like Kate and Katie as nn's, so the K makes more sense because of that too.
vote up1
Catherine is soft and sophisticated, whereas Katherine is mundane and too easily reducible to the odiously hackneyed Katie.
vote up1
odiously hackneyed Katie. goodness.
vote up1
I like both spellings, but I'll go with Katherine because I like the possibilities of Katie and Kate.
vote up1
Catherine. It looks softer and prettier. The 'K' looks too harsh for this name, in my opinion. A bit off topic, but I don't understand why the Duchess of Cambridge, whose name is Catherine, goes by "Kate" when she could have gone by "Cate". It kind of bugs me.
vote up1
Yeah, really. I agree. And although I do prefer Katherine, one thing in Catherine's favor is that I like the nickname Cat, and if I wanted Cat, I'd definitely go with Catherine and not Katherine because I wouldn't like the initial letter switch.
vote up1
I prefer Katherine by far to Catherine. But why? I think it's because Katherine looks younger and more vibrant to me than Catherine. Katherine is a young beautiful woman and Catherine is dowdy and matronly and middle-aged. I think it's because one of my favorite books is a biographical novel about a young and beautiful Katherine and her name is spelled Katherine and not Catherine and I read that book for the first time when I was very young and it's colored my perception ever since.Another thing that causes this perception is Catherine of Aragon, whose name is sometimes spelled with a K but usually with a C, and whenever she's written about it's emphasized that at the time that Henry VIII decided he wanted to annul their marriage she had grown middle-aged, stout, and dowdy, and she compared very unfavorably to the younger and sexually magnetic Anne Boleyn.Maybe this is silly but I think that's it.
vote up1
KatherineIt was my favorite name for years. I prefer Katherine because it's closer to the name's original form. I love how soft and strong the name is at the same time.
vote up1
wrong spot. sorry
vote up1
I definitely would go for Catherine. There is something about Katherine that appears dated to me. Catherine just has more history.
vote up1
I prefer French Catherine to English/German Katharine because it looks softer. The Katherine spelling just looks like a smooshed version of both.

This message was edited 9/8/2013, 2:57 PM

vote up1
Katherine, just because I think it looks better with the 'K'.
vote up1