View Message

This is a reply within a larger thread: view the whole thread

[Opinions] Re: 17 French Baby Names That Are Prime For An American Takeover
in reply to a message by Elena
Some of these names are just beautiful, and even where I recognize tradition--even with a subtle twist, these names still seem new! It would be great for the US to inherit these names; which in general it already would among a distinct few, but the masses of White-America, methinks, would be too strongly dependent upon the familiar customs of its youth - wherein novelty is raised to praise not by merit but by customs of peers within its own social class, which to me is utterly sad and deplorable.

This message was edited 11/9/2015, 2:47 AM

Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I disagree. I think the "masses of White-America" are becoming more apt to adopt exotic names that they think hold value in that culture. I am seeing more and more Krea8tive, foreign, or dusty choices on the middle and upper class these days. Not to mention the proliferation of unusual noun-names like Rainbow and River. The majority of Americans (to me) seem to want to stray from tradition or the "customs of its youth" rather than embrace them. Other than honoring, I am not seeing standard name choices anywhere. I am enjoying the diversity actually.

This message was edited 11/9/2015, 5:53 AM

vote up1
I enjoy diversity too; and I still hope that more grow to accept non-traditional "white-names" than those who have already embraced them. I would tend to think that, if a standard were set to ratio, though many may or may not concur on a fixed calibration, the numbers would reflect lesser favor toward non-traditional "white" names, yet while I hope more would accept "non-traditional standard white names than previously, I still fear we still have many leagues to travel before we arrive at full acceptance. However - I hope that you are correct and that my thoughts are inaccurate. However, am a guy with a name attributed to females; yet I find this to be a blessing.
vote up1
I think if we consider the differences in opinion between those who are past the age of having children, versus those who are currently choosing names for babies... we find a disparity. Those who have chosen names already and are aging I see a consistent reaction in favor of traditional names and against the foreign, krea8tive, and alternative. Those naming kids right now, seem (to me) to be up for almost anything!
vote up1
That is wonderful! I find little difference when I mention my name while in formal situations; however, this would often be among an aging generation--though not by any means, exclusively, as a few younger folks would often be present. I will admit that folks in their twenties have little or at least lesser difficulty with the unique assignment of my name, so this part has grown easier; although some folks of any generation absolutely love it.

This message was edited 11/10/2015, 3:57 PM

vote up1