View Message

[Opinions] Beatrice or Beatrix (more)
Haven't thought about these two in a long time. Beatrix or Beatrice and why?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

My daughter and my mother both have Beatrice as their fn, and my grandmother had it as her mn. QED!Also, Beatrix is too Dutch-royalty. And shortens to Trixie, which is (a) unfortunate and (b) canine,
vote up1
I like Beatrice. I *adore* Beatrix.
vote up1
I prefer Beatrice. To me it looks much cleaner and more understated without that X and it avoids the nickname Trixie.
vote up1
Beatrix!Beatrix feels more feisty and fashionable, like vintage 50s/60s film star stylish, and I have better associations with her. Beatrix Potter adds a more whimsical aspect, and a character association I have with Beatrix (and why I love nn Trixie) reinforces that vintage feel. Beatrice is nice, and I like her, but I don’t love her and she doesn’t have the same meaning to me as Beatrix does.
vote up1
This articulates my own thoughts perfectly.
vote up1
1. Beatriz
2. Beatrix
3. BeatriceIt'd usually just depend on the combo, though.
vote up1
Beatrice recently made it on my list. I'm loving it. I pronounce both with three syllables.My history with this name: I first heard it from a friend who was obsessed with Beatrix "Trixie" Belden growing up and swore her first daughter was going to be Beatrix "Trixie". I thought it was weird, not my style. While I still constantly think of her when I see the Beatrix, the connection isn't as strong for Beatrice. Then I read Divergent, and absolutely love the nn "Tris". Anyway, I don't think it sounds old at all, but I've never actually met a Beatrice / Beatrix of any age. I can see it on any age, and with multiple nn options I feel it's the best name on my list.ETA - while I typically do like odd letters, I agree that Beatrix just doesn't look as good, real, classic? Not sure what I'm going for there but point is I don't like it.

This message was edited 7/13/2018, 6:39 PM

vote up1
I think they're both ugly. If I had to go with one it'd be Beatrice, but I'd always call her Bea.Beatrix just sounds like 'beer tricks'to me. I love Beatrix Potter but that doesn't make me like the name any more (and her name was actually Helen anyway).
vote up1
I honestly don't care for either but my pick would be Beatrice. I prefer the look and sound of it slightly more. Plus, it sounds more of an "actual" name to me and not something too fictional as what 'Beatrix' conjures up. I have tried to warm up to Beatrice but I just can't. The name is too dated for my taste and just conjures up images of a harridan-type. Like, the given name of an old and mutual disliked teacher that everyone wishes would retire already.
vote up1