View Message

[Opinions] Theodosia
I saw this name in Hamilton and liked it. It's complex and unusual and pretty. Do y'all think it's going to zoot out of obscurity? It felt very workable in the context of the song.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Too elaborate and overdone for my taste. It might become very popular as an alternative to Theodora, though, since Theodora is becoming rather popular itself.
vote up1
I love the song, Dear Theodosia! I think it is really pretty and a nice alternative to Theodora.
vote up1
I adore it! I hope its popularity doesn't soar because of that dumb musical.
vote up1
I wondered where you stood on Hamilton!
vote up1
I saw it on Broadway in 2015 and greatly enjoyed it, but the show's politics are lame and distasteful. "Dear Theodosia" is a lovely song, though, and I was touched by Renée Elise Goldberry's and Leslie Odom, Jr.'s performances!
vote up1
Would be happy for you to expand on this if you want - I wonder if you mean the political message of the show itself? Or how society handles the show? Or what. lol I don't wonder super urgently though so if you don't want to get into it that's OK too. Yes they did very well, didn't they? The cast was invested well into their characters I feel
vote up1
This has been a favorite of mine for well over a decade. I remember posting about it years and years ago and most didn't like it lol Then Hamilton came about and has made it more well-known, a little less "weird", and more acceptable-- which I love!
vote up1
A few years ago when I first listened to the soundtrack of the Broadway show, I read that Theodosia had a small uptick in usage because of Hamilton. It looks like it had two surges in usage-- in 2017 and 2020 according to babycenter. I don't think it will zoot out of obscurity quite yet, if only because of it being recognized in the play and song, and because people like me fell in love with it upon hearing it. Will it be popular or get on the top 1000 name list? Probably not.
vote up1
Maybe it'll have a little swell in 7 years or so, after it's percolated.
vote up1
I forgot Hamilton is on Disney+ now! I'll have to check it out.I love, love, love Theodosia. It's so feminine and strong. Theo and Thea are both great nicknames!
vote up1
Came out on July 3! Big splash everywhere. My mom threw a little party about it. She's the only Hamilton maniac in the family though so we all just sat there quietly while she was pumping her fists etc.
vote up1
Aw, that's kind of adorable lol
vote up1
Oh man I hope it doesn’t shoot up in popularity. I love it & and want it to stay in the sweet spot of uncommon but somewhat familiar due to its similarity to Theodora and its use in Hamilton.
vote up1
I don’t think it’ll rise much in popularity, even with Hamilton being so popular. It’s been the biggest musical on Broadway for some time now, and nothing has happened. Plus, when I introduce Theodora I can tell that most people aren’t immediately falling head over heels for her name, and it’s arguably the more accessible and well-known of the two. I like Theodosia a lot. No surprise there! I think the nickname Dozey would be cute, especially since kids are kind of adorable when they’re tired. (Blinky eye-rubbing tired, not tantrum tired.)
vote up1
I don't think it will rise in popularity just yet, but I like it a lot.
vote up1
This name isn't new to me via "Hamilton", because I've been aware of it since I was a kid and first read "My Theodosia" by Anya Seton, which is about the same Theodosia in "Hamilton". After liking (but not loving) the book for all these years, I was intrigued to listen to the song about Theodosia from "Hamilton." Alas, I found it disappointing. I just don't like "Hamilton". Anyway, I've thought it a pretty name since that first exposure. Much better than Theodora. But Theodosia Burr is referred to as Theo throughout "My Theodosia" and I'm not a fan of that nickname, so it's not a name I would use.
vote up1
I didn't care a whole lot about the song either. I wonder if I'll grow to be addicted to Hamilton like my mom. I think it's more about the whole impression of the entire thing than the individual songs, and I don't think LMM's strength is in ... melodic writing.
vote up1
I absolutely hate this name. I would usually try not to use the word hate, but here I have to. I really, really hate it. It is sickly and sugary and dusty and fussy and all the other bad things. It's like ... Theodosia is a sticky old dessert with canned cherries covered in cat hair.

This message was edited 7/5/2020, 3:13 AM

vote up1
BahahaaOmg. That is the best description of a name i've ever heard.
vote up1
How do you feel about Theodora?
vote up1
I like Theodora a lot! It's the dosia part of this that skeeves me out.
vote up1
Not familiar with Hamilton but Theodosia feels too much for a real person .I can imagine it very well on a cat.
vote up1
Aw! Cute cat name
vote up1
I can see it being used for nicknames Theo and Thea. It is very pretty and with the popularity of Hamilton it might crack the top 1000.
vote up1
I'm a big Broadway fan so this name has been on my radar for a few years. I adore it and I think it's more usable now than it has been in the past hundred years, especially since Thea is a cute and popular nickname.Besides that, I've been writing about a Russian character named Feodosia for a decade now and I think that's really pretty too.

This message was edited 7/4/2020, 10:46 PM

vote up1
I way prefer Feodosia, I think I just dont like The- names but they are both very pretty!
vote up1