Certainly not witchy!
My middle name is a very googlable surname ultimately derived from the same root as
Tiffany (
Theophania), and I love dwelling on the concept of Theo-Phania aka
Epiphany. I like that
Tiffany has this shallow image that has this awesome, ancient theological concept beneath it. I also like the association with
Tiffany lamps - with the light shining through them - it seems appropriate to the meaning.
Molly is the chicken soup of names. So friendly and easy to deal with.
If I had to give a witch a non-witchy name. Well my friend
Beth is witchy and I don't think her name is witchy at all. It is grounded and friendly and practical and open and sweet and dependable. These are all great qualities for a witch. So I'm gonna go with
Beth.