I never cared for it. Super 80s dated.
It has two things going for it: Shakespeare and the nickname
Jessie.
That's about it. I always thought the -ica part was extremely ugly together with the harsh J-beginning. I also dislike
Jess.
A
Jessica born nowadays would find herself having the same name as 30% of her friends' moms. Not sure if that is so great. I wouldn't love to have been called
Carol or
Linda (nowadays they almost sound cool again but in the 90s they were super unfashionable).
I love
Jessie but as I find it too nickname-ish on its own can dislike
Jessica and can't really warm up with
Jessamine etc. either I wouldn't use it. Also because there are at least 50 names on my list I like better.
It fits right in with names like
Amanda,
Stephanie,
Matthew, Christopher...Classics that are now 80s dated.
So I immediately want to create sibsets like
Jessica,
Amanda and
Matthew.
It definitely needs a more unusual and classic middle name:
Jessica CalliopeJessica PersephoneJessica LouisaJessica CamilleJessica EmmelineJessica RosemaryJessica RosalindJessica Marigold
I would stay away from typical filler middle names (
Jessica Anne,
Jessica Rose) and common or dated names (
Jessica Lauren,
Jessica Michelle). The former make the name even more boring and the latter make it sound like a complete 80s combo.