Emily - cute, classic, pretty, 90s dated, terrible meaning.
Emma - good meaning but so so so bland.
Emme - kind of silly? and celeb trendy. No offense! But it looks like it should be pronounced EMM. I would never pronounce this as EM-mee.
Emmy - this is cute but to childish as a full name.
Emmie - this is a bit more elegant but still too cutesy.
Emy - looks misspelled.
Emi - this is Japanese to me and pronounced EH-mee and I like it.
I would pick
Emily but I wouldn't use any in real life.
Please rate my list:
https://www.behindthename.com/pnl/6232