I don't like either of them. I think if I were named Huntington I would pine for a nicer, shorter personal name instead. Or at least a good nickname. Probably her name won't get confused with anyone else's, anyway. I might be willing to bet you some baked goods that when she's 13 or so, she'll change it to
Quinn or
Virgil or
Lenore or something.
I met a young
Imogen about ten years ago (they were Aussies) and her mother called her Ibby. Too twee for my taste, but it's alright, just nms. I can see how it's appealing to people, being what it is, easy to say and having no "baggage" really. I don't care for
Imogen myself because it starts just like "image" in my accent, and also looks like a name for a biotech company.
- mirfak