I find it unpleasant. I had a colleague whose daughter met her partner while working as a barmaid. Her favourite drink was sherry, and his was Amstel beer. They had a daughter who had three names: a harmless fn, followed by Sherry Amstella.
In my opinion, most things would be better than Sherry. Cheryl is OK, I've got a Cheryl cousin, but I'd prefer Shirley.