View Message

Shelby/Abigail
My niece already has a daughter named Abigail (nicknamed Abby). Personally, I think Shelby would be a great name for her new sister(if it's a girl). They both seem to flow so well together. Anyway, I was jsut wondering what people out there think of Shelby.P.S.- checkout my other post a few posts south.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

I love Shelby. I used to dislike it because it's cutesy and trendy, but now I know two ~11 year old girls named Shelby (one is in my class) and they've made me feel differently about it. It's still cutesy and trendy lol, but I don't mind any more. I probably wouldn't use it on my own initiative, but if S suggested it I wouldn't say no.I don't like Abigail so it's hard for me to think of things that go with it, but I don't see anything wrong with Abigail and Shelby as siblings.

This message was edited 7/24/2008, 6:27 AM

vote up1
Abigail is nice, but I really dislike Shelby. It's surnamey and unfeminine, and don't see why it flows so well with Abigail.
vote up1
Shelby, I'm not fond of.
Abigail is a strong, beautiful name. Miriam? Dorothy?Brigit? Susan, or perhaps Suzanne?
vote up1
I like the idea of pairing Shelby with Abigail. Its not very popular and it beats pairing a trendy Abigail with a Hannah or Sophia by a mile. So go for it.
vote up1
I think Shelby is sweet, but I'm not sure I like it with Abby. I generally dislike repeating sounds in sibsets (shel-BEE and AB-ee), but then again that's just my personal tastes.
vote up1
I like Shelby. It's cute and not very common. And, yes, I do think it works well with Abigail.
vote up1
I think Shelby is really cutesy and annoying. I really dislike the sound and I can't really compare it to historical feminine Abigail.
vote up1
I agree about Shelby, but I also despise Abigail. One of the reasons I hate Abigail is that it sounds UNfeminine to me.But it is indeed historical, and from that point of view it does really clash with Shelby.
vote up1
TrittoI agree with Janan.However, Abigail has recently become more and more popular. I'm getting sick of it. Though I'd choose it over Shelby, I am not particularly fond of either name.
vote up1
DittoI despise the name Shelby, and I can't picture it on anyone but an obnoxious little girl. I'd feel gypped if I were named Shelby and my sister something so lovely as Abigail.
vote up1
I agree
vote up1