View Message

Shirley
I actually really like Shirley for a girl. What do you think? Chances of a comeback?It sounds fresh to me. It is in the same style as Ashley, Bailey, Lindsay, Ainsley, Kinsley - just has been used longer.
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Never cared for it. To me, Shirley is always going to be seen as being dated and not in a charming sort of way. I don't see it making a comeback anytime soon, at least not monumentally.
vote up1
Between how dated it is and the fact that my sister-in-law's name is Shirley, and she's a loud, brash person, it's hard for me to judge it objectively. I'm still trying. That's all I can say for the moment.
vote up1
Meh. I don’t think it has chances of a comeback. Definitely doesn’t feel as modern as Ainsley, Lindsay, or even Ashley.
Plus, I keep thinking of Shirley Temple - both the actress and the drink.
vote up1
I love it, and I would love to see a new wave of Shirleys.
vote up1
One of my friends had a daughter back in January and actually named her Shirley, after her grandmother... and, honestly, that's who I picture when I hear the name Shirley. It's super dated. Aside from that baby all the Shirleys I know are 60+. Until the baby I'd never met yet a young Shirley. It feels very old, very old fashioned, and I really don't know that it will get a comeback any time soon. Maybe once the current generation of Shirleys have passed on and the name has been 'dead' for a little while it may have a chance but that'd be like 50 years from now. I also don't hear it in the same style as Ashley, Bailey, etc A similar ending doesn't make it the same. Those names you listed are all very youthful.
vote up1
I like it because it hasn't been used for a long time! It is genuinely pretty, and I think it's far enough in the past to be used without too much fuss. I'd be more likely to use it for a cat, preferably with long fur, but that's just me.
vote up1
No
vote up1
NoThat one's a hard NO for me.
vote up1
It might have an outside chance.
I think it's kind of cute, in a grandma way.
vote up1
Yes, it's a random surname that became wildly popular, probably because of Shirley Temple.I think it should stay in the past. It has potential to come back to honour grandmothers of girls born today but I don't see it being a Top 10 name.
vote up1
It was already wildly popular when Shirley Temple was named.
vote up1
Doesn't its popularity originate from Charlotte Bronte's " Shirley"? I believe it was a male name before that.
vote up1
Yes: in the book it's stated to be a male name that needs some explaining when used on a female! Conversely, in the later LM Montgomery "Anne" books, Anne and Gilbert's youngest son gets named Shirley, that being his mother's maiden name.
vote up1