I don't know about the lovemaking, but I certainly can imagine a judge, mayor, President, or M.D. with the first name of Sayler. If spelled Sayler or Saylor, it's really just a surname transfer given name, and since we've had Presidents named
Franklin, Rutherford,
Chester,
Grover,
Woodrow,
Calvin,
Dwight, and
Lyndon, I see absolutely no reason why we couldn't have one named Sayler.