View Message

[Opinions] Lilia or Lydia?
This is a constant question in my head: which is nicer, Lilia or Lydia?To me, Lilia looks and sounds beautiful; I would even go so far as to say that it is the #1 prettiest girls' name out there. But I'm also drawn in by the similar-sounding, classic Lydia. I like the Biblical and Pride and Prejudice references and that Lyddie is much less of a common nickname than Lily.So, what are your thoughts?
Archived Thread - replies disabled
vote up1

Replies

Lydia!
vote up1
I like the contrast of the sounds in Lydia. It rings out clearly, where Lilia sounds a bit more mumbly. Lilia is pretty, but it can feel lost among so many other Lilys, Lilianas, &c.
vote up1
Lydia! Classy and beautiful.
vote up1
Lydia!
vote up1
Lydia. It's always been one of my favorite names. I actually don't find the Lyd- sound that heavy; it's more like a solid place to take off into the air of the -ia. The whole name sounds like a graceful little leap in the air.Lilia, probably because I'm not used to it, sounds unbalanced. Lily is shorter and still sweet, while Liliana has body and flow. I don't know if that makes sense, but it's the best way I can describe it.
vote up1
Lilia looks as if the -n has fallen off Lilian. I prefer Lily, and that's saying something.Lydia is nice enough, and Lyddie is very nice. I was disappointed to meet what I thought was a Lyddie, years ago, when I found out she was actually Elizabeth and Liddie had been her slightly older siblings' best attempt at Libby.
vote up1
I like Lilia very much. Lydia is just ok to me. I think it sounds prettier in languages that aren't English. The LID part sounds really clunky to me in English. I had a Russian student named Lidiya and I loved the way she pronounced her name. It sounded so light and graceful when she said it.
vote up1
I only like Lilya, oddly, which I believe is Ukrainian. I don’t care for Lydia, Lilia, Lillian, or Lily.Only Lilya hits the right notes.
vote up1
I prefer Lydia, which I love. I tend not to like names that are vowel-heavy, which Lilia is.
vote up1
I prefer Lydia only slightly. Lilia is soft and sweet but Lydia manages to be pretty, strong, elegant etc all at the same time.
vote up1
LydiaLilia is sweet, youthful, and demure.Lydia is beautiful and self-possessed. I really like the Biblical Lydia; she was an intelligent business owner and a leader in the early Christian church. The Lydia in "Pride and Prejudice" is one of the biggest draw backs for me personally. I would love to know the meaning of Lydos, the name of the semi-legendary king who gave his name to the region of Lydia in Asia Minor.
vote up1
I love both. I prefer Lydia as a full name, and Lilia as a nn. That probably sound weird but I just find Lydia more complete, and Lilia a sweet nn for Liliana or such.:)
vote up1
I prefer Lydia - I love Lilia too, but Lydia is one of my very favourite names. Lilia is, in my opinion, even nicer with the Polish pronunciation, which is quite similar to LEE-lya.
vote up1
Lydia, far and away. Lydia is beautiful! I know Lilia has its own history and (related) origin story, but to my ear it just sounds like somebody thought Lily sounded unfinished or juvenile and shoved a random ending on it. I still like it, but I like Lydia better. I like the name Laelia better as well.
vote up1
Lydia
vote up1
Both are lovely, so I see your dilemma. But I have to go with Lilia. It’s just so beautiful and the Hebrew meaning is just gorgeous. Lydia and Lydie are lovely too, but the meaning is lacklustre.
vote up1